3 ms·
> A catalogue of hand-curated links has increasing value as the quality of Google results goes down. Who will pay for its creation, maintenance and hosting? Wh
by mschuster91 5y ago
> A catalogue of hand-curated links has increasing value as the quality of Google results goes down.
Who will pay for its creation, maintenance and hosting? Who will judge ranking, disputes, hacks?
Who will have an eye on discrimination issues? Whose jurisdiction will be relevant (think GDPR or the Australian press "gag order" law in the case of that cleric accused of fondling kids)?
Who will take care that the humans who will get exposed to anything from generic violence over vore/gore to pedo content get access to counseling and be fairly paid? Facebook, the world's largest website, hasn't figured out that one ffs.
These questions are ... relatively easy to bypass with an automated engine (all issues can be explained away as "it was the algorithm" and IT-illiterate judges and politicians will accept this), but as soon as you have meaningful human interaction in the loop, you suddenly have humans that can be targeted by lawsuits, police measures and other abuse.
- rchaud 5y agoIt doesn't need to be a corporate enterprise that has to worry about all those things. People already share directories of links via Google Docs, Notion notebooks and the like.
- derefr 5y ago> as soon as you have meaningful human interaction in the loop, you suddenly have humans that can be targeted by lawsuits, police measures and other abuse. In theory, you could have a curated directory whose hosting works like ThePirateBay, and whose maintainership is entirely anonymous authors operating over Tor (even though the directory itself holds nothing the average person would find all that objectionable.) Of course, there's no business model in that...
- mschuster91 5y agoTPB is not a good example since they're allowing everything except pedo content, thus drastically shrinking their moderation workload. A site that wants to be compliant to the law in the major jurisdictions (US, EU) can't operate that way, not with NetzDG, copyright and other laws in play.