4 ms·
> It’s a simple package and not without its faults but when you consider the pace of technological development since then it’s appalling how much CAD has steppe
by bsder 5y ago
> It’s a simple package and not without its faults but when you consider the pace of technological development since then it’s appalling how much CAD has stepped backwards.
CAD is bad because there are too few users.
Work backward from the Altium statements. Altium has about $200 million in revenue. Altium website claims licenses are about $2K-ish. That's a maximum of about 100K paying users (reality is likely closer to 25K).
If you have 1,000 features, you have 100 users per feature.
In reality, those features follow a power law. Everybody uses the same basic features, but if you use a slightly off-path feature, you may be the only user.
Open source is the only path forward in this space because code can accumulate over time and users can consolidate over time.
The problem is that CAD coders are even rarer than CAD users, and they can get get paid quite a lot in their day job--why should they do this for free?
- hulitu 5y ago> CAD is bad because there are too few users. CAD is bad because it is made by SW developers who implement requirements and have no idea how the SW is used. I do not need all the toolbars at once. If the buttons are too small they are difficult to press, if they are too big they eat valuable space. > If you have 1,000 features, you have 100 users per feature. :) Most of the features are used sporadically. > In reality, those features follow a power law. Everybody uses the same basic features, but if you use a slightly off-path feature, you may be the only user. No. There is a workflow. During this workflow you may, or may not need special features depending of the object being designed. > Open source is the only path forward in this space because code can accumulate over time and users can consolidate over time. There are some very good open source tools (like Magic layout system) but they are good because the developers also use those tools. > The problem is that CAD coders are even rarer than CAD users, and they can get get paid quite a lot in their day job--why should they do this for free? AFAIK there are no "CAD coders". There are SW developers who got the job to write the code. Finding people qualified in multiple domains is hard.
- bsder 5y ago> There are some very good open source tools (like Magic layout system) but they are good because the developers also use those tools. Sorry, the Magic layout system is NOT a good tool. It has a lousy DRC/extraction system based on corner stitching which requires that everything be lambda-based rectangles. Ever seen a professional VLSI layout person use rectangles?--they almost never do. There's a good reason why they use paths. Good layout systems also link the schematic and layout in real-time. A lot of PCB systems even do this now. I can go on and on and on about Magic. None of it is good.