4 ms·
Apple can read all of your iMessages and texts out of your non-e2e iCloud Backups, and they can see all of your Photos in your iCloud Photos. iCloud syncs all
by sneak 5y ago
Apple can read all of your iMessages and texts out of your non-e2e iCloud Backups, and they can see all of your Photos in your iCloud Photos. iCloud syncs all of your contacts to them, too. iCloud Backup is on by default so it’s safe to say that Apple can read everyone’s iMessages (even despite their claims of e2e encryption, which are now bogus due to the backup backdoor).
Every time you open the App Store, it sends your permanent, unchangeable device serial number to Apple along with your Apple ID, which is tied to your name and address and phone number and payment cards. (You can’t get an Apple ID without a phone number.) Many apps are App Store only, and on iOS it’s all apps.
Having location services on means your exact location is being sent in realtime over the network to Apple constantly (it’s not just passive GPS reception). Launching apps sends identifiers over the network to Apple in realtime (unencrypted, even, so even your ISP can see), so they know what apps you use, and where and when you use them. This all happens even with analytics disabled.
Even if you have iCloud off, using Siri sends your contacts and other data to Apple.
Books and Music track what you listen to, how often, and on which devices, under your Apple ID.
Even if you don’t use Apple for email, iCloud syncs your Mail app recent addresses autocomplete to Apple, who can then see who you correspond with.
All macs and iphones and ipads maintain a persistent 24/7 connection to Apple push servers with a client certificate linked to the hardware serial number of the device. If you aren’t using external VPN hardware at all times, this continuously leaks your city level location and ISP to Apple on a per-serial basis (which is linked to your Apple ID and name due to App Store use above). They know when you leave home and switch to 4G. They know when you arrive at work. They know when you travel to another city, and which hotel you stay in. They get all of this data even with location services off due to the invisible phone-home built in to the OS, and this happens even if you don’t use iCloud or any App Store apps.
Apple’s “commitment to privacy” or whatever presupposes that you don’t need or want privacy from Apple themselves. It is thus entirely natural for Apple staff to continue in this vein, as most Apple customers have surrendered their most private and sensitive data to iCloud and other Apple services already.
(In 2019, they turned over more than 30,000 customer accounts of data to the US federal government under FISA orders (per Apple’s own transparency report on their website), which are not warrants and do not require probable cause. Even if you trust Apple staff completely, there are reasons not to trust the federal investigators to whom they are compelled to leak your data without suspicion of a crime.)
- ipython 5y agoDo you have pcaps to demonstrate Apple leaking your identifiers in clear text? That’s very surprising to me.
- greyface- 5y agohttps://sneak.berlin/20201112/your-computer-isnt-yours/ https://sneak.berlin/20201112/your-computer-isnt-yours/ https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25078034 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25078034 https://blog.jacopo.io/en/post/apple-ocsp/ https://blog.jacopo.io/en/post/apple-ocsp/ https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25095438 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25095438
- sneak 5y agoThe requested pcaps are linked from here: https://sneak.berlin/20210202/macos-11.2-network-privacy/ https://sneak.berlin/20210202/macos-11.2-network-privacy/
- ipython 5y agoThank you!
- ThePowerOfFuet 5y ago>Apple can read all of your iMessages and texts out of your non-e2e iCloud Backups You are conflating iMessage in iCloud with iCloud Backup. If you have iMessage enabled in iCloud, your message history is no longer under your sole control. If you have iMessage in iCloud disabled, and iCloud Backup disabled, nobody has your messages except you and the recipient. (If they have it enabled then your messages with them will be stored that way.) I personally use iMazing for automated local backups to my own equipment, and have iCloud Backup disabled.
- sneak 5y ago> You are conflating iMessage in iCloud with iCloud Backup. I'm not. MIC on, being the default, puts the MIC secret key used for sync into the iCloud Backup. This means after the first nightly backup, Apple can read your iMessages in realtime as they are synced via MIC. > If you have iMessage in iCloud disabled, and iCloud Backup disabled, nobody has your messages except you and the recipient. Yes, and these settings default to on, and resultantly virtually every iMessage recipient has both of these settings turned on, which means that Apple receives your iMessages from the other end of the conversation, even if you have them off. Again, we are back to the original claim: Apple can read all of your iMessages in real-time. I also have iCloud disabled and do local backups. I also have FaceTime and iMessage disabled for this reason. I also have an external VPN router that is used for all Apple device traffic that blocks push service connections and other telemetry collectors (xp.apple.com, pancake.apple.com, et c).