41 ms·
Presumably you would not agree that this "type of talk": 1. identifies a particular type of person 2. characterizes them in a specific way that, like other gr
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
Presumably you would not agree that this "type of talk":
1. identifies a particular type of person
2. characterizes them in a specific way that, like other group characterizations, is simultaneously an exaggeration, a truth, and a point of view
3. encourages us to think about that the assumptions we carry around about what a "default" model for life should look like
I know people who are very well described by this sort of language, even though (like any group characterization) it necessarily does not capture their whole selves. The description reminds me to not just accept that these people (or anyone else) have some natural born right to whatever position they end up in life, and that we can question whether we do in fact value what they do and say. It leads to questions like "Why are almost all the people who do <insert type of work> like this?", in ways that we frequently do for other sorts of work but tend not to ask about "success".
- seieste 5y agoThis comment seems rather vague and general. Could you provide an example where you’ve used this technique?
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThe precise case in question: > "more fragile white males with degrees from Princeton" That specific language recasts (in my mind) people I might have seen as extremely confident extroverts. At this point in life, I think that the "recast" take is more accurate than the way I used to see them, but it's not something I'd have come to spontaneously. Encountering language like this helps to raise questions about what is really driving people, whether or not my own answers to that question are correct.