3 ms·
> But I have learnt that Microsoft Edge is as bad as Google Chrome (for me) because they are mirroring Google Chrome with regards to Manifest V3. In case you
by judge2020 5y ago
> But I have learnt that Microsoft Edge is as bad as Google Chrome (for me) because they are mirroring Google Chrome with regards to Manifest V3.
In case you don't know, Edge is built on Chrome's engine - using Edge is just as bad as using Chrome if you want the web to be more open with different vendors having a say in how it works.
- stonemetal12 5y agoIt is, but there is the question of how much effort MS puts into it. So far it seems to be that it is not so much "built on" as it is a low effort reskin.
- nvrspyx 5y agoI don't know much about the internals of Chromium, but I'd say it's more than a "low effort reskin". Not including the UI changes like vertical tabs and collections, there's also a lot of underlying changes/improvements made like PlayReady support (for e.g. 4K Netflix playback), better scrolling support, tracking protection, Windows-specific improvements, memory/performance improvements, PDF annotation, web capture, etc. Granted, Microsoft are contributing most of these underlying improvements back upstream to the Chromium project, so the gap between them will remain small. Second to Google, Microsoft is the most prolific contributor to the Chromium project, so I think "low effort reskin" is a bit of an undermining to their efforts. With all of that said, Google is still the gatekeeper, Microsoft's contributions don't really solve the Chromium browser monopoly, and Microsoft is being really scummy with their push for Edge (i.e. Windows and Bing annoyances about it). I'd still prefer to have more independent browser options like Firefox.
- PascLeRasc 5y agoIt's so funny that Microsoft copied Chrome's left space between the edge of the screen the the first tab, but they didn't realize that Chrome still counts that as part of the tab (https://imgur.com/a/hI2XrcX https://imgur.com/a/hI2XrcX). So if you try to quickly mouse over to your leftmost tab on Edge, you'll end up clicking the menu section instead and un-fullscreening it.
- megaman821 5y agoChromium seems to me a bit analogous to Linux. Chrome, Edge, Brave, etc are link Red Hat, Ubuntu, and so on. Between the varied stakeholders and the various web standards groups, I don't see Google going off the deep-end and introducing truly unpopular changes. I do see some advantages though, since browser engines are near the same complexity of an OS, it make sense to cooperate on one main engine.