3 ms·
I wonder if this is a back-firing of the push for people to be "nice" and "professional". Open source maintainers used to have the sterotype of being rather ha
by bawolff 5y ago
I wonder if this is a back-firing of the push for people to be "nice" and "professional".
Open source maintainers used to have the sterotype of being rather harsh, and basically telling people to f off if they had stupid questions, didn't RTFM or didn't follow cultural norms. And dont get me wrong, there's a lot wrong with that, but maybe it was also that way for a reason.
- fxtentacle 5y agoAgree. I'm active in some communities that are unfriendly if not outright hostile towards newcomers. I'm sure they lose a good amount of potential contributers that way. But the few newcomers that remain are highly motivated.
- pteraspidomorph 5y agoNow that I think of it, that's also my experience. If I really need a project to do whatever (and can't implement the feature myself), I shut up, let the horrible attitude wash over me and put hours of effort into testing and providing helpful information, and maintainers usually mellow out eventually. If I hadn't done all of that work, the maintainer would have had to do it. Sure, they're much better equipped to do it and can probably do it in a quarter of the time it takes me, but multiplied by fifty tickets... Oof.
- watwut 5y agoNice professional people have large backlogs ignored for years, say no to requests or delay work. Otherwise said, being nice and professional does not imply you will immediately implement every feature request or bug report. It does not imply you will not block/mute abusive people.
- beckingz 5y agoBeing nice and professional just means smiling as you get a dumb request and being open about your intent to prioritize the request alongside everything else.
- planb 5y agoYou can be harsh in a nice and professional way though.
- kjs3 5y agoI can't second this enough, and it's the other side of that whole "put your code on Github and use it as a resume". If I'm looking to hire someone, and I look at their Github repository and it's full of nasty, unprofessional responses to PRs and such, it's a pretty safe bet I don't need that attitude on my team.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mncharity 5y agoIn the 1990s, the perl and python communities both had to cope with an endless stream of novice confusion. One grew community norms which included recreational disparagement. The other, in part in reaction, was explicit and firm: if you can't be polite and professional just now, your contribution to the community can wait. The contrast between the two cultures was very dramatic.