3 ms·
You don't own the open source software you write, so you don't have the right to make demands of its users beyond what the license stipulates. That companies ca
by krapp 5y ago
You don't own the open source software you write, so you don't have the right to make demands of its users beyond what the license stipulates. That companies can make billions with your software and not owe you so much as a cup of coffee is not the dark side of open source, it's an expression of the same freedom that allows you to fork and reuse any FOSS software under the same terms.
If you want to require payment from anyone who uses your software, use a proprietary license and charge money. The "fair share of revenue" in free for free and open source software is correctly "zero."
- ans123 5y agoPlease stop the misinformation: Open source authors do own their IP, but are altruistic enough to license it to others. In the long term, altruism only works if there aren't too many leeches. Up to 2010, OSS authors at least got recognition, could stay aloof and in general weren't little corporate bitches. Now, this has changed, so there is no longer any point of writing OSS for free. The corporations have won their long term game, using the freedom propaganda until they owned most of it.
- muyuu 5y agoonce you distribute your code under a permissive licence, you typically don't get to undo that surrender of control over your work in that sense ownership is relative, for better or worse writing OSS will always make sense, for certain kinds of projects and perhaps without expecting much compensation fo it most of the time
- krapp 5y ago>Open source authors do own their IP, but are altruistic enough to license it to others. And when they do, they give up many of those rights in the process. At the very least they give up any right to tell anyone else what they can or can't do with "their" code. The entire premise of FOSS is that software belongs to the community, not to authors. It is fundamentally collectivist, anti-ownership and anti-capitalist at its core, and only recognizes concepts like IP and copyright out of legal necessity. >Now, this has changed, so there is no longer any point of writing OSS for free. The only thing that's changed is that a new generation of open source developers have lost the plot now that software has become a billion dollar business and suddenly they want to get paid for work they voluntarily gave away for free. The point has never been compensation. Again, if programmers want to get paid, they can use a proprietary license, or write code for a corporation and get a paycheck. Or get a second job. Otherwise the complaints from people who likely have never contributed so much as a dime or a single PR for any of the FOSS code they use, and who chose the FOSS path out of a belief in its moral superiority to the capitalist incentives of proprietary software, are starting to get tedious.