14 ms·
> I'm not blaming Apple for not stopping these scams Why not? You should blame them. They have positioned themselves as the gatekeepers. Why? To extract profit
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
> I'm not blaming Apple for not stopping these scams
Why not? You should blame them. They have positioned themselves as the gatekeepers. Why? To extract profit from application developers. However, such a powerful position also comes with expectations and responsibilities. They should absolutely not be allowed to get away with gross negligence.
We absolutely must blame them every single time they fail to keep malicious software out. They are responsible for that man's losses and should fully indemnify him. Had they not approved that software, it would not have happened.
Nobody cares about their "scale" or how "difficult" it is for them to determine what is and isn't malicious. They have assumed that responsibility by gatekeeping their devices and therefore any failures are directly attributable to them.
- rawtxapp 5y agoI agree, I think they should help him, but I also think it would open a whole can of worms. The fact is, no matter how much time/energy/effort they spend, they will never eliminate all scams, scams would just become more and more sophisticated. This doesn't mean, they should just give up, but having been through the review process, they are already doing quite a bit. So that would mean, they will make it much harder for apps to get approved in the store (and it's already a very painful process), so you'd only end up with apps from large developers which is not ideal. We are seeing a similar dynamic with Youtube which has become rather "ban-happy" as in they don't want to take risks, so would rather ban content than try to reduce false positives, because at a certain scale, you just can't identify content with good precision/recall.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> I also think it would open a whole can of worms Absolutely. Apple should be afraid of holding the gatekeeper position. Anyone should. When people can install and use whatever they want, safety becomes their responsibility. They should open up their platform and let people do their own due dilligence. If they assume that responsibility and then neglect it, they absolutely can and should be blamed for any problems.
- nwienert 5y agoYes and likewise, car manufacturers should remove seatbelts and airbags. They simply encourage reckless driving, and by giving the false sense of security / assuming the gatekeeper role, they should be liable for any accident.
- heavyset_go 5y agoWeird, I can flash whatever code I want to on my car's ECU. There's even an entire subculture dedicated to modding ECU firmware.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CharlesW 5y agoFlashing your car's ECU is illegal. Or more specifically, federal and state laws make it illegal to operate an automobile on the open road or highway after you've altered a vehicle's emission control devices (which includes the ECU). In contrast, it's legal to jailbreak an iPhone.
- tekknik 5y agoYou absolutely cannot, unless you have an open ECU to begin with. Typically this is only sporty type cheap cars (evo, wrx). But even if you were to take on such and endeavor the difficulty of such a task and the knowledge requirement will scare off the unexperienced
- matheusmoreira 5y agoThe Apple review process is not in any way equivalent or even similar to seat belts and airbags. Not even the government can be fully blamed for bad drivers since people don't actually need a driver's license in order to drive.
- nwienert 5y agoPunishing companies for adding protections to their products is an insanely backwards incentive. May as well turn off sandboxing, and lock screens. If they ever break, it’d be a liability!
- lozenge 5y ago> they are already doing quite a bit. They must be focusing on the wrong things then. Certain categories are filled with scam apps at the top ranks, including scam subscriptions.
- jay_kyburz 5y agoI think what Apple _could_ do is insure that there is a real person that can be held accountable by law enforcement in the users jurisdiction. That way a user has some legal recourse in the event they are wronged. Nobody wants Apple to be judge and jury, we have judges and juries for that, but it would be nice if they could tell us who to go after when we have to. If they can't do that, I don't think its unreasonable for us to ask Apple to be responsible any losses, then let Apple seek compensation for their losses from the app publisher.
- atatatat 5y agoCensorship is also easier when you have an AI to blame the "mistake" on.
- jpalomaki 5y agoThe real solution I see would be to charge money for listing apps in the store. And not small money, but significant, non-refundable fees. Enough to actually check and verify the software by competent humans and also just to make scams more expensive (you would need to pay $5-10k upfront, like Google requires for certain Gmail apps). But I don’t like that kind of approach, so therefore I would be careful in demanding Apple to fix the problem. Any fix they come up with, would likely cause troubles for small players.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoThe real solution is to stop being a gatekeeper. Just let people install and use whatever they want.
- votepaunchy 5y agoHow does this stop or in any way slow the proliferation of scam apps?
- matheusmoreira 5y agoIt doesn't. It absolves Apple of any responsibility in the matter.
- dev_tty01 5y agoWhy does anyone want to help Apple? Shouldn't we be focused on user safety?
- matheusmoreira 5y agoWe're not helping Apple. We're holding them accountable for what they make available on their store which they advertise as "curated and safe".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- euroderf 5y agoApple's 30% cut suggests to an untrained observer that for every seven hours of coding you do, they could do three hours of verifying that your app is not a scam. What happens instead is, I guess, robo-verifier spends 2 milliseconds. Ka-ching!
- mhh__ 5y ago> Why not? You should blame them. I also think it's easy to forget just how much Apple could spend on this if they actually cared