3 ms·
Although all (bar one) of the points made seem sound to me the take-away should probably be "and then go and do bitcoin anyway". Maybe I'm an idealist, but allo
by roenxi 5y ago
Although all (bar one) of the points made seem sound to me the take-away should probably be "and then go and do bitcoin anyway". Maybe I'm an idealist, but allowing people to freely signal what they think is worth supporting financially will cause more good than harm.
I think there is a strong argument that even with all the negative externalities listed, the positive are even greater. I mean, what if the world's billionaires are eventually forced to transect on a public blockchain? A lot of shadiness will suddenly become really hard to hide. Net crime may well reduce; we don't know what we don't know in that sphere.
> Funding "rogue states" such as North Korea and Iran."
Now on to the point I disagree with. Find Iran on a map. Look left of it and right. You'll see two countries invaded by the US on the flimsiest of pretexts. The US not being able to use financial means to rub salt in the wounds of people it wants to bully is a win for the world. This is a positive externality.
- andreskytt 5y agoThere are two views, I suppose. Stalin did build an industrial state. It was based on slave work causing death and untold damage to millions. But it did allow them to persist against Germany. Which is all good as long you are not the one being slaved, that tends to shift the viewpoint significantly.
- jolux 5y ago> I mean, what if the world's billionaires are eventually forced to transect on a public blockchain? That’s never going to happen because the technology is not going to get that far. How do you have effective monetary policy with a deflationary currency? Governments and central banks are not going to willingly give up that power, nor should they. Blockchain currencies just do not make sense on the macroeconomic level. Moreover we already have solutions for investigating financial crime, it would be much easier to improve policy and enforcement there than overhaul our economy for what would be at best an indirect benefit.
- brazzy 5y ago>I think there is a strong argument that even with all the negative externalities listed, the positive are even greater. I think you have to be completely deluded to believe that. > I mean, what if the world's billionaires are eventually forced to transect on a public blockchain? A lot of shadiness will suddenly become really hard to hide. Wasn't one of the big promises of crypto anonymity so that it would be the salvation of the prosecuted? And now it's supposed to completely eliminate anonymity and that is supposed to be a good thing? Schrödinger's Blockchain? >Net crime may well reduce; we don't know what we don't know in that sphere. We have ample hard evidence that the opposite is the case.
- leppr 5y agoCare to provide any sources to that "ample hard evidence"?
- brazzy 5y agoOP's article has a bunch of them. it opens with one.
- leppr 5y agoWhat I want to see a source for is your claim that there is hard evidence for the opposite of "net crime being reduced", not random anecdotes and opinion pieces. I see nothing there indicating a quantitative increase in crime victims or number of crimes being committed due to cryptocurrency.
- brazzy 5y agoThere's entire new forms of crime being enabled by cryptocurrency. Most notably, ransomware is doing 20 billion dollars worth of damage annually (increasing quickly), and depends pretty much 100% on cryptocurrency for payment: https://cybersecurityventures.com/global-ransomware-damage-costs-predicted-to-reach-20-billion-usd-by-2021/ https://cybersecurityventures.com/global-ransomware-damage-c...
- roenxi 5y ago> Wasn't one of the big promises of crypto anonymity so that it would be the salvation of the prosecuted? The Bitcoin blockchain is a public, permanent ledger of every transaction ever made. The people claiming it is anonymous were always being optimistic. I think it might be strictly worse than the existing banking system for privacy. People trying to use Bitcoin for anonymous crime are in for a very nasty shock at some point. It is a better idea to go old school and bank with HSBC.
- hobofan 5y agoThe shady stuff that the world's billionaires are doing is in large parts already publicly reported, and already pretty appaling, and few people seem to care. Not downright criminal stuff, but by now I doubt that changes anything.