7 ms·
As others have mentioned, I also wonder how much of this annoyance to return has to do with the failed open-office concept. People more-or-less occasionally li
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
As others have mentioned, I also wonder how much of this annoyance to return has to do with the failed open-office concept.
People more-or-less occasionally like having their own place during work where they can some action (e.g. closing their door) to focus 100% without interruption.
Cost-cutting open-office plans that let management see their flock typing away destroyed this option, and covid has reminded people how valuable and productive this option is/was (for those at home with this option).
We are now in new territory, as we are experiencing the end of the first pandemic during the information age. What we decide now will resonate for many years.
Something to think about: for most millennia of human experience, where one worked and where one lived amongst the family and community were one and the same. It’s only a blip in post-industrial history have we had this situation of leaving the family (et al.) behind to pull levers and receive $coins.
If the internet lets us go back… that would be huge
- ethbr0 5y agoEveryone would be going back into the office... if there wasn't a shortage of skilled workers to fill positions. As the labor market is, companies have to bend to some of labor's demands in order to attract and retain talent. This isn't the worst state of affairs.
- viraptor 5y agoYou say that like the company's purpose is to be as bad to employees as possible. I get where the idea comes from, but that's not true everywhere and companies did remote work before it was forced on them. It doesn't have to be "bend to some of labor's demands", but rather "choose most effective hiring and working strategy".
- glhaynes 5y ago>You say that like the company's purpose is to be as bad to employees as possible. Where? I don’t see that in what they wrote.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- viraptor 5y ago> Everyone would be going back into the office... if there wasn't a shortage of skilled workers to fill positions. A different way to read that is: people would do as told and not ask to work remotely because they could get replaced. But that applies only if the company does not care about the employees and wants cogs instead.
- ethbr0 5y agoAlternative rationale: institutional inertia prevents change. Remote work is a big change. Ergo, absent an exteral driver of change, companies will continue doing what they've always done.
- ryanSrich 5y agoThis is a failure of the job to be done though. The JTBD for the execs at these companies forcing in person work isn’t to be efficient. It’s to make themselves feel good. They feel better when they see asses in seats. It’s really that simple. If efficiency had literally anything to do with it we would have all been remote since 2005.
- granshaw 5y agoMisread as assets in seats. Still works
- underwater 5y agoI think that's a little simplistic. Lots of people are just as productive, or more productive, at home as they are in an office. But I've also had a lot of other people tell me they struggle to work remotely. It really depends on the individual, where they are in their career, and what type of project they're working on.
- thelastknowngod 5y agoI think there is a significant amount of companies (and a substantial portion of the government) in the US that operates on a philosophy like "How much can we extract from people before there is any push back?" It is a nation entirely built on micro transactions.. I am sitting in an airport right now. Baggage carts are free to use. The last time I flew in the US it was a $5 fee. Why? Because it's just enough to extract value from us but not enough for anyone to complain in a significant way. I don't think that companies are deliberately trying to be awful to workers. They are just using the standard American model.. "How much can we get away with?" The country is in desperate need of widespread unionization efforts.
- refurb 5y agoDo you think this is a uniquely American issue? Having lived in other countries it’s worse.
- Mertax 5y agoI don’t think all companies are as adversarial towards their employees as this makes it sound. Great companies recognize they benefit when they are proactively trying to do what’s best for the employee as well as the company. Companies that I’ve seen do it well have an executive level employee advocacy position. Typically in a human resource department, but less concerned about the policy and regulatory requirements and is specifically tasked to be a champion/voice for employees.
- kortilla 5y ago> The country is in desperate need of widespread unionization efforts. No thanks. I don’t like working with clock punchers nor do I want to get paid as poorly as programmers in Europe/Canada. Until unions in the US stop prioritizing seniority over competence for pay, they need to stay the hell away from this industry.
- underwater 5y agoGood pay is nice, but it's not the only variable to the equation. I worked received great pay in the US, but made the decision to return to Australia. I have some regrets, but the lifestyle I get from not being in the Bay Area pretty much offsets any pay difference. What I miss most is the scope and pace of the work and the incredibly intelligent people I got to work with. Thankfully I'm beginning to see the genesis of this in my local market.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThe company's purpose is to make as much money as possible. That means that their interest is to make their employees work as much as possible while paying them as little as possible. If they try to make you do better/more work a nicer or a ruder way is an implementation detail. The goal is always to extract as much work as possible from you at the lowest price. Sometimes the goals of the company converge with the goal of employees. Most of the time they exist in a state of frozen conflict. It sucks, but that's just how the employer/employee relationship must work out in general.
- musicale 5y ago> shortage of skilled workers to fill positions Companies are willing to do anything to attract skilled workers short of raising wages.
- zaphirplane 5y agoI wonder if the open office is broadly disliked or hater by a very vocal minority on the internet I haven’t heard in person hating on it Assuming people don’t mean some dystopian 30 rows
- koonsolo 5y agoMost people that I know get very lonely working from home. I saw it in my developer group, where all single people would try to go to office during covid, because it's so lonely at home. Colleagues with small kids are unable to get any work done when there is no babysitter. I personally have no problem working from home, but I see that's a real exception. And even I don't mind going to the office once every week, just to get the social interactions and be away from home once in a while. So I think you are right that people who don't want to go to work at all is a real exception.
- slavapestov 5y ago> Colleagues with small kids are unable to get any work done when there is no babysitter. Yeah, but if they’re small enough to need a babysitter you can’t leave them home alone and go to the office either.
- koonsolo 5y agoTrue, but this example is a pure Covid situation. Sorry to mix those two.
- hn8788 5y agoMy experience has been similar to yours, with the addition that married people without children never wanted to go to the office. It was basically the best of both worlds; you aren't lonely, plus your spouse (usually) understands that they shouldn't bother you while you're working, while kids don't.
- mapmap 5y ago>Colleagues with small kids are unable to get any work done when there is no babysitter. Speak for yourself. Give credit where credit is due to the heroic efforts of employed parents who got work done and took care of the kids.
- spamizbad 5y agoPart of me suspects that at least some of the WFH productivity boost companies see is attributed to home offices being quieter. My home "office" is on the attic landing, with no door, and I have a 3 year old running around the house. It's been quieter and easier to stay focused here compared to my company's open plan office. I went back to the office for the first time in over a year a few weeks ago and I was flabbergasted at how low my productivity was despite working hard the whole day.
- gumby 5y ago> It’s only a blip in post-industrial history have we had this situation of leaving the family (et al.) behind to pull levers and receive $coins. A bit of history: actually that was the industrial revolution and until the the 1970s the open plan office was the norm even for white collar workers (the cubicle was invented in the late 60s as “liberation” from the open plan). I remember being shocked when I first saw the open plan return, back in 2000, and since the productivity of offices (for programmers) and cubes was so well documented I was sure it was simply some weird experiment. In the end though it will be trade off between the value of the ad hoc interactions vs the cost of real estate. The kind of close-minded people who consider their colleagues (ahem, “workers”) to be merely fungible resources will make their decision solely on the price of real estate. Note I started my first “mostly remote, work over the net” company in 1989. It’s not a new idea either.
- jacquesm 5y agoTwo main reasons that I'm aware of: (1) employer distrust of their employees being hard at work when not in full view of said employer and (2) the cubicle area put an automatic lower limit to the amount of floor space a single employee would occupy.
- znpy 5y agobefore the pandemic i would have killed for my own cubicle. nowadays i just don't want to go back to the office.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- armchairhacker 5y agoI thought open-offices were mostly a dud: they were trendy a few years ago, then most companies switched back when they realized the open offices actually decreased productivity.
- xyzzyz 5y agoI haven’t heard of a single company that switched back.
- humanlion87 5y agoI think, unfortunately, the big tech companies might disagree with your take on this issue. They continue to invest millions in new and "re-designed" buildings based on open-office plans.
- geerlingguy 5y agoSadly it seems like the trend has only picked up. I haven't seen a new office buildout in the past 5 years that had individual offices except for sometimes for the managers.
- kmonsen 5y agoTo be honest even though I hate open office with a passion and cannot concentrate single person office is not ideal at least for me. A large part of my time at google we had a shared team office for 4-10 people and that was never an issue and has all of the collaboration. Another time my desk was in a noisy open landscape next to the main reception and a busy cafeteria where the kitchen staff would often chat loudly and play video on their phone using the speaker.
- cgb223 5y agoNot an Apple employee but for me it would be the commute not the office that’s the pain point Driving or even bussing down or up or across the bay to get to Apple is a huge stressor. Doing it every single day both ways easily kills 2 hours of my life. If I stay home and work instead I am better rested, more relaxed, and consequently more productive
- WORMS_EAT_WORMS 5y agoThis is interesting on so many levels. Not saying I don’t feel for a terrible commute. But has anyone ever been on Blind? A lot of these people are kind of awful, rich, a-holes. Now coming in the office is too much to ask? The best part is what can Apple really do here… I think a reasonable compromise is cut their salaries by around 20% if you optionally work remote and donate it to education in less fortunate communities in these cities. Be interesting to see how many people show up to the office.
- lanstin 5y agoI would take that in a heartbeat. Also fifty percent cut for par work during child rearing years (which I was able to negotiate for myself but was a thought fight). And yes I am blind. I suspect it is a bit of posturing mixed in with a bit of not hiding ones true but shameful beliefs.
- pitterpatter 5y agoKeep in mind, the users on blind are not necessarily representative.
- WORMS_EAT_WORMS 5y agoI know. Just, no shortage of verified Apple emails commenting. In all seriousness, I am just concerned for greater income equality from increased remote work.
- draw_down 5y agoThe bosses aren’t any better, friend.
- unityByFreedom 5y ago> for most millennia of human experience, where one worked and where one lived amongst the family and community were one and the same Hunters and foragers went out. Working from home seems like a blip compared to that.
- hzay 5y agoHunters & foragers went with their family. Both activities were group activities done with family & tribe.
- cableshaft 5y agoHunters and foragers didn't sit at a desk or in a car all day when they went out either. They also got to head back whenever they hunted/gathered enough food, instead of stick around until they put their 8 hours in. "A study back in the 1960s found the Bushmen have figured out a way to work only about 15 hours each week acquiring food and then another 15 to 20 hours on domestic chores. The rest of the time they could relax and focus on family, friends and hobbies." https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2017/10/01/551018759/are-hunter-gatherers-the-happiest-humans-to-inhabit-earth https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2017/10/01/5510187...
- musicale 5y ago> the failed open-office concept That to me seems like the main reason to hate Apple Park [1] and to prefer individual walled offices like Infinite Loop used to have: >"Greg “Joz” Joswiak (VP of product marketing, 1986–present): They built this campus fast, and it was obviously a bright shiny object. Everybody wanted to move in. It was a gigantic shift in the way we worked, because we went from being in cubes to, all of a sudden, literally every person had an office." [2] [1] https://www.dezeen.com/2017/08/10/apple-park-campus-employees-rebel-over-open-plan-offices-architecture-news/ https://www.dezeen.com/2017/08/10/apple-park-campus-employee... [2] https://www.wired.com/story/apple-infinite-loop-oral-history/ https://www.wired.com/story/apple-infinite-loop-oral-history...
- rorykoehler 5y agoI've been working remote for over a decade and if/when I go to the office I basically get nothing done. It's great for morale and building relationships but for all individual contribution work it's awful.
- slver 5y agoApple doesn't use an open office.
- spacedcowboy 5y agoYes, they do. Source: I work at Apple Park, at least notionally