4 ms·
I've always been the "that won't work" person in whatever organization i've worked in for the last 35 years (fortunately for most organizations, I've been self-
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
I've always been the "that won't work" person in whatever organization i've worked in for the last 35 years (fortunately for most organizations, I've been self-employed for the last 25 years). I think this article is needlessly negative. I view my "that won't work" contributions as the reason why it did work (eventually).
As others have noted, it's important that "that won't work" is accompanied by actual reasons (and reasoning). But it is often important to have a nattering nabob of negativity, especially with a younger cohort full of positivity and possibility and not a lot of battles fought. Most of the time, it can be made to work, but often that requires the injection of a voice mostly full of objections, problems, issues, overlooked items.
- dtgriscom 5y agoLike you, my superpower is to "look for trouble." For some reason, my mind looks for the potential weak spots in any plan, and I'm darn good at it. Of course, it's much easier to find them in other people's plans than my own...
- notahacker 5y agoAlso, the nattering nabob of negativity is important in reminding people that prioritising the thing that probably won't work or is difficult to make work has the opportunity cost of not prioritising things that will work. Sure, the negative voice might occasionally deter you from finding an incredible solution, but the positive voices about ambitious ideas are always deterring you from focusing on fixing other stuff. I view my lack of success as the "that don't won't work" person in one role as the reason why we had a number of half finished products that didn't work or didn't sell. At least if a team agrees to try something that probably won't work because the rewards are so huge (or the implementation is easy and it's just the results that are questionable) they've thought about the resources needed, and won't either give up at the first hurdle or plough far more into it than it'll ever be worth.