11 ms·
It really depends on both latency and bandwidth. A reasonable POTS modem does ok on latency, but bad on bandwidth. So roundtrip is fine until you send too much
by toast0 5y ago
It really depends on both latency and bandwidth.
A reasonable POTS modem does ok on latency, but bad on bandwidth. So roundtrip is fine until you send too much data (which is real easy, modern initial segment limit of 10 combined with a 1500 mtu is more than a second of download buffer). If you kept the data small, many round trips would be okish.
On the other hand, traditional geosynchronous satellite always has terrible latency, so many round trips is bad regardless of the data size... One big load would be a lot better there.
- giantrobot 5y agoPOTS modems don't do great on latency either. I never managed under about a quarter second latency on dial-up. The first hop (your modem'd DAC and the ISP modem's ADC) was usually around 75-100ms all by itself. So even today with pretty fast networks (compared to the heyday of modems) you're easily looking at base latency of a quarter second.
- icedchai 5y agoModem latency was crap. That was another reason a 64K single channel ISDN connection felt so much faster, even though the bandwidth wasn't that much more. ISDN latency was wayyy better since it was digital: 10 to 20ms vs 200ms minimum with an analog modem. Some early ISPs I worked with started with 56K leased lines. The latency there was like night-and-day compared to a 56k modem.
- giantrobot 5y agoMy first experience with an ISDN connection was mind blowing. I had only ever used analog modems prior. So I'm just expecting faster downloads for large files and pages would load faster. It was a 64k line so I was expecting it to be twice as my modem at home. Web pages just appeared (modulo Netscape connection limitations). A fresh page load felt as fast as a cached page load on my analog modem. It was nuts. It was most noticeable in a handful of games of Quake I played. I got to experience the joy of being a Low Ping Bastard and actually landing a few hits on people.