3 ms·
>therefore we should find a more clear-cut way to define what firearms are too dangerous for people to have access to and pass efficient legislation to limit th
by salawat 5y ago
>therefore we should find a more clear-cut way to define what firearms are too dangerous for people to have access to and pass efficient legislation to limit that access"
>A well regulated(1) Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep(2) and bear Arms, shall not be infringed(2).
(1)Regulated, at the time of authorship of the Constitution, was meant to communicate the state of being in good or well working condition, not "constrained by executive or legislative dictat".
(2)To keep implies not only the mere act of possession or ownership, but the ability to maintain in a functional and useful state, which also implies that any tools or consumables needed for this maintenance are similarly protected.
>https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/keep https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/keep
(3)Infringed:
Definition of infringe
transitive verb
1 : to encroach upon in a way that violates law or the rights of another infringe a patent
2 obsolete : defeat, frustrate
intransitive verb
: encroach —used with on or upon infringe on our rights
>https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/infringe https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/infringe
Open/shut case really.
Stop trying to encroach on a Constitutionally guaranteed Civil Right, and these types of problems won't emerge. Your end state is in violation of the highest law in the entire country. It is not a tenable state of affairs in the U.S. that citizens should be able to be denied the capability to exercise a Constitutionally guaranteed right by default.
Yes, I'm a hardliner. No, I'm not salty because I want a minigun. Too much maintenance and ammo is expensive as all get out. More than anything I want the legal word torture that props up most firearms regulations to end, because all it does is set precedents for even more brazen violations of plain English rendered Constitutional rights under the guise of Public Safety.
Even machine guns are not regulated under the auspices of "Public Safety" and instead, are handled under the banner of regulating interstate commerce through taxation, with particularly high penalties for being caught having tax evaded. Yes, I find the closing of the machine gun registry in 1986 to be questionable in the legislative sense, as it's an end run around saying machine gun registering is henceforth illegal/impossible (unconstitutional) by instead restricting what the Federal Government can spend money on to not include maintaining and updating the registry (debatable legit on the cover, but second order or higher thinking renders this highly suspect). There's a contention there between the power of the purse, and the restriction of laws Congress can legally make that thusfar, there is a great deal of reticence on anyone that floats up to the Supreme Court to resolve.
Frankly, I've seen it as a madness that's only been getting worse over the years, and has served to rot the quality of legislation ever since it was enacted. That's just me though.
- PoignardAzur 5y agoYou're making a few assumptions here: - That the US Constitution matters to me. - That I give any moral value to legal minutia. Frankly, as someone living in a country where firearm access is strictly restricted (and, as a direct consequence, people aren't regularly shot in their car by a twitchy police officer who thought they were reaching for a gun), I find the whole Second Amendment thing baffling. Like, I get the practical reasons to want to own a gun, but the knee-jerk way gun advocates will react to any attempt to restrict gun ownership, no matter how meek the attempt or how dangerous the gun (is the right to own a M16 really necessary for public safety?), strikes me as disturbing fanaticism. Legalese aside, I really don't get the impression that widespread gun ownership is a net-benefit from a consequentialist point of view. I'm open to being proven wrong.
- rsj_hn 5y ago> - That the US Constitution matters to me. > - That I give any moral value to legal minutia. Fair enough, but you are commenting on a post about a judicial ruling, not a post about a constitutional amendment or an act of the legislature. The moment judges decide to ban something or uphold a ban on something based on consequentialist decisions rather than interpreting the law is the moment we go from a rules-based government to government by judicial fiat, and that has some very bad consequentialist repercussions. This was a bad law that needed to be overturned, and it was.
- PoignardAzur 5y agoI guess that's fair. I was commenting more on the language used and the article posted by the FPC than the ruling itself. But I don't think it's a productive debate either way.