3 ms·
> Non-Indians who commit crime on the reservation I grew up around are already searched and detained by tribal police until state police arrive. My reading of
by gumby 5y ago
> Non-Indians who commit crime on the reservation I grew up around are already searched and detained by tribal police until state police arrive.
My reading of this decision is that different circuits had resolved this question in different ways (a classic reason for the SC to accept a case) and in particular the ninth circuit (not where Oklahoma is) had resolved it in a particularly poor way. So in this case a plaintiff in Oklahoma, convicted of some particularly serious charges, tried to use some lack of clarity in the law to get out of them (and TBH why shouldn’t he?). Fortunately the SC declared that throughout US territory, the sensible and, really, the only practical way, is how things should be.
I suspect the sensible path was already the default even in jurisdictions where the matter was unsettled or even wrongly settled (the Ninth circuit’s case, apparently). After all despite the dreadful headlines, most sensible policing is just what was at the root of this case: the cop stopped to see if someone needed a hand. It didn’t start as a “jurisdictional” case and if the cops had to think of that every time they’d never get anything done.