10 ms·
If you're trying to write software for others, it's going to end up as mediocre and probably not entirely what they wanted. Stop for a minute and notice how ab
by edw519 18y ago
If you're trying to write software for others, it's going to end up as mediocre and probably not entirely what they wanted.
Stop for a minute and notice how absurd this statement is.
99.9% of all software ever written was for others. Was it all mediocre and "not entirely what they wanted"?
This is the entire reason for systems analysis and requirements specification. You don't need to do any of this for the software you're writing for yourself. You must do all of it and do it well when writing software for others; that's how you insure that it's exactly what they want.
- stcredzero 18y agoI interpret the post as just a long rantish way of saying: "If you want to write good software, you've also got to use it." In my experience, there is a lot of software out there that is deemed valuable by management, produces good ROI, but is despised in some way by its users. I'd say the majority of it. (And I've been in many dozens of shops as a consultant.) That will fly for internal software for a big company, but not for a web startup. Another way of saying it: really doing "systems analysis and requirements" right puts you in the user's shoes. That's the part that matters, not the artifacts produced by the process. (I'm preaching to the choir here, I know.) In fact, the "systems analysis and requirements" process matters not a bit, only the result, which should be getting the real user experience into the heads of development.
- axod 18y ago99.9%? That's just insane. You're saying that all the games developers never play their own games? How about people writing languages, compilers etc. You don't think they use them?? I'd say the majority of open source software is written for yourself rather than others. People contribute the most when they are using that software. You don't have to be the only customer/user of your software, but it helps to be a customer/user of your own software. That's what I mean by writing for yourself.
- edw519 18y agoThere are over 800,000 programmers working in the U.S. alone, an overwhelming majority employed by someone else. http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview/id/43888.html http://answers.google.com/answers/threadview/id/43888.html I'm saying that the ERP, accounting, banking, claims processing, ecommerce, order entry, scientific, etc., etc., etc. software they work on is for someone else. They dwarf those working on games, compilers, and open source. Welcome to the real world.
- Retric 18y agoMost: ERP, accounting, banking, claims processing, ecommerce, order entry software sucks. Scientific software is often started by someone who uses it and tends to work well.
- edw519 18y agoMost: ERP, accounting, banking, claims processing, ecommerce, order entry software sucks. You're probably right about that. But enough of it works to run the world. No small feat.
- sapphirecat 18y agoThere's a yawning chasm between "works" and "doesn't suck".
- axod 18y agoWhere did I say you have to not be employed by someone else??? That's pretty much irrelevant.
- jon_dahl 18y agoI think there's a difference between an engineer working for someone, and the person making the product decision. If you're a developer for a software company building accounting software, and you don't have much use for accounting software personally, you're probably fine. But if you're defining the product, you're much better off if you've been a user of accounting software in the past.
- swombat 18y ago99.9% of all software ever written was for others. Was it all mediocre and "not entirely what they wanted"? Having lived and breathed (and somehow survived) in the enterprise environment that employs the vast majority of the programmers out there, I can agree with that proposition whole-heartedly. Yes, 99.9% of the software that gets written is mediocre at best. A shockingly large proportion of it is downright abysmal, but most of it is mediocre. Thankfully, we don't get to see most of that software since it is safely locked away inside the mega-corporations that pay hordes of programmers to write it.