4 ms·
Do they tie the progressive line on "Make the police accountable and maybe not spend mountains of money on buying them tanks tanks and maybe not let them litera
by vkou 5y ago
Do they tie the progressive line on "Make the police accountable and maybe not spend mountains of money on buying them tanks tanks and maybe not let them literally get away with murder?"
Or is that not a 'progressive' line? (In which case, why the hell haven't we gotten it yet?)
I think the likely explanation for this conundrum is that people don't support <whatever strawman of the week is used to attack a caricature of a position>.
- throwaway894345 5y ago> Do they tie the progressive line on "Make the police accountable and maybe not spend mountains of money on buying them tanks tanks and maybe not let them literally get away with murder?" If you’re asking “do black Americans want police reform”, then probably yes considering 90+% of all Americans favor police reform of some kind. So to answer your other question: > Or is that not a 'progressive' line? (In which case, why the hell haven't we gotten it yet?) Not uniquely, no. Why we haven’t gotten it yet: probably because our politics are broken by intense partisanship among other things. Frankly this isn’t a corporate issue (beyond some shallow virtue signaling), so it just doesn’t become a legislative priority. > I think the likely explanation for this conundrum is that people don't support <whatever strawman of the week is used to attack a caricature of a position>. This is a well-documented dodge. Leftists have been very clear that they want the police abolished. The media tried to make that message more palatable in advance of the recent presidential election by suggesting it was a euphemism for moderate police reform, and leftist activists clarified that they literally want to abolish the police. This is very explicitly not a caricature.
- Aeolos 5y ago> Leftists have been very clear that they want the police abolished. Citation _very much_ needed. In my experience this is not a position of the left, beyond maybe some fringe <0.1% groups. Stating that as a "position of the left" as a fact merely reinforces what the GP said: "I think the likely explanation for this conundrum is that people don't support <whatever strawman of the week is used to attack a caricature of a position>. "
- xupybd 5y agoThis is not definitive or representative but it is one very public example https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/12/opinion/sunday/floyd-abolish-defund-police.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/12/opinion/sunday/floyd-abol...
- tolbish 5y agoWould a link from someone who doesn't want the police abolished persuade you, or have you already decided those people on the left do not count?
- throwaway894345 5y agoWhat a silly dichotomy. Just because you aren’t convinced by N=1 doesn’t mean you’ve closed your mind to a possibility. Can we grow up?
- tolbish 5y agoLeftists have been very clear they want police held accountable.
- xupybd 5y agoThere are views on all ends of the scale. Most, even conservatives want some police reform.
- JamesBarney 5y agoThis is the whole point we're arguing about up front. That activists have a oversized influence on what we discuss. Less than half of black people support defunding or reducing the police presence but that conversation has smothered all discussions of more realistic and popular reform.
- wccrawford 5y ago"Leftists have been very clear that they want the police abolished. " No, most aren't crazy enough to think that abolishing the police is better than what we have. Instead, they ask to "defund" the police, and then redefine "defund" to mean that many of their daily services should be given to others more qualified for peaceful resolutions, without carrying weapons, and police should be available for backup of those situations. I personally remain unconvinced, and I think we'd see a lot of the people doing those services injured because they went into dangerous situations without adequate protection. But I can't deny that the police have shown a lot of poor judgement over the years, so something needs to change.
- Chris2048 5y agoWho do you consider to be responsible for CHAZ?
- Chris2048 5y agoA simple question. But since this question was +2, and is now -2; I guess there are a lot of people who don't want it to be asked..
- JamesBarney 5y agoI think the best reforms are make police officers pay for their own insurance, break up the union, and pay officers more to compensate for the reduced job security.
- throwaway894345 5y agoI also wonder if better vetting and training would help, and of course increase pay accordingly.
- listless 5y ago“Instead, they ask to "defund" the police, and then redefine "defund" to mean that many of their daily services should be given to others more qualified for peaceful resolutions, without carrying weapons, and police should be available for backup of those situations.” I’m so tired of these rhetorical games. It’s dishonest and we need to stop accepting it as a legitimate form of discourse. No respect for people and politicians who do this.
- IndySun 5y ago>Leftists have been very clear that they want the police abolished. Lazy rhetoric will always let one down in a big way. At the very least, as one is making broad, sweeping generalisations, one will totally miss what the real issues are, and the real problems.
- IQunder130 5y ago>whatever strawman of the week is used to attack a caricature of a position Is it really a strawman when a non-negligible number of people in your political camp espouse a position without so much as a hint of irony or exaggeration? Denying the existence of the radicals won't win you any credibility with fence sitters and moderates.
- rayiner 5y agoProgressive activists get more air time than they have political power. It’s like how, if you watched the mainstream media before Super Tuesday, you would have thought Elizabeth Warren was a front runner for the nomination. But, like with the democratic primaries, voting tends to collapse the bubble. Concrete example of this. Progressive Asian organizations attacked Andrew Yang for his normal Democrat take on the police: https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/activists-andrew-yang-anti-asian-hate-crimes.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/activists-andrew-yan.... But of course Yang is the overwhelming front runner among actual Asian voters in NYC. Another example is NYC Pride banning the NYPD from marching in Pride: https://www.gaycitynews.com/nyc-pride-overrules-membership-vote-police-policy/ https://www.gaycitynews.com/nyc-pride-overrules-membership-v... > Less than a week after Heritage of Pride (HOP), or NYC Pride, announced a ban on police contingents through 2025, the organization’s members voted on May 20 to allow the Gay Officers Action League (GOAL) to march armed and in uniform — but HOP’s executive board subsequently stepped in and set their own policy. Progressive activists really do believe the things they say. Usually they don’t get their way because it’s a democracy and actual voters don’t support those things. As to “straw men”—I was rankled last year when my law school faculty declared themselves “gatekeepers of white supremacy” in a school townhall meeting: https://jonathanturley.org/2021/05/27/brandeis-dean-declares-yes-all-white-people-are-racists/comment-page-1/#comments https://jonathanturley.org/2021/05/27/brandeis-dean-declares.... People told me, “well most liberals don’t think like that.” I suspect that’s true, your average Biden voter doesn’t. But there’s 14-15 elite law schools in the country, and the faculty of at least one of them does think like that. This activist mindset isn’t widespread, but it’s often concentrated among people who have significant platforms. A lot of faculty, young political staffers, etc., do think like that. It’s not straw-manning to call out that behavior.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoYour average Biden voter is either not a leftist or probably voted against Trump. I was with you until that point, because what you're pointing out is that the US is intensely conservative on a national scale, especially compared to Europe. Biden would be center right, at best, in Europe.
- 5y ago