4 ms·
The important question is, “who cares?” (Non rhetorically). There is a useful scientific question of interest to a small nu,ebr of people: if the virus transfe
by gumby 5y ago
The important question is, “who cares?” (Non rhetorically).
There is a useful scientific question of interest to a small nu,ebr of people: if the virus transferred from Petri dish to humans, what can we learn about bio safety practices for future research.
There is an unuseful question which is what most people are asking: “how can I find someone to blame after the fact for what is essentially a natural phenomenon?”
Not impressed by humanity on this one.
- oh_sigh 5y agoPresumably it matters because if it was a GoF research leak, we either need to suspend GoF research or increase security at labs doing it. Is it going to be the GoF researchers who call for a moratorium on GoF research? Possibly but there is a clear conflict of interest there. A powered up virus escaping from a lab is almost definitionally not a natural event
- rsync 5y agoI will repeat here what I mentioned in the previous HN thread from this morning ... [1] If it's a lab screwup that's relatively good news because we can fix lab screwups - it is not an indictment of our globalized, urbanized way of life. However, if it is a natural event then it, along with SARS and MERS are starting to create a trendline that suggests our globalized and urbanized way of life has crossed a threshold and we should expect this regularly. That's a much tougher problem to solve ... [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27394771 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27394771
- silicon2401 5y agoThis is a great example of why I find comments like "who cares" disingenuous. A good faith question would sincerely ask who cares, and why it's significant. The comment you replied to was essentially a discussion-shutdown attempt, but as you showed, there are very legitimate reasons to care.
- gumby 5y agoNot at all: while a rhetorical “who cares” is indeed an attempt to claim the entire discussion worthless, the actual question I explicitly called out, “who are the people who care and what are their motivations” is precisely not a conversation stopper. And the reply (to which you reply) expanded the scope a bit, which was interesting.
- tomjen3 5y agoI care a ton if this was a cover up. It seems extremely likely that this was the case, based on the attempt to shut down any discussion of this. And if that is the case the lesson should be never to do this kind of research ever again, upon the worst possible punishment we can come up with.
- ncmncm 5y agoI.e., only ever do it in national military labs, and do not publish results.
- gumby 5y agoThat class of research has a long history and metahistory, in particular around more virulent diseases like smallpox. I consider it a legitimate tool for important work. And there was unambiguously a coverup in either case