2 ms·
I consider the state of my mental health to be pretty solidly strong, but if I was facing an overzealous prosecutor telling me (convincingly) I was certainly go
by kelnos 5y ago
I consider the state of my mental health to be pretty solidly strong, but if I was facing an overzealous prosecutor telling me (convincingly) I was certainly going to jail for a very long time, I might take my own life. It's disturbing and sobering to think about it, but there it is.
I think the question here is: would Aaron Swartz have committed suicide at that particular time if not for the prosecutorial overreach he was mired in? I suspect the answer there is pretty safely: no. Would someone else in his position perhaps not have committed suicide in that situation? Sure. But he did, and it was clearly in no small part due to the circumstances he was in. I'm fine assigning much of the blame to the persecution he suffered under the US government. They wanted to make an example of him, by using a poorly-written, over-broad law that has traditionally been applied selectively depending on the needs of law enforcement. And sometimes when you put people in that position, they can't take it.
If you don't agree, I guess that's fine, but quibbling about semantics here is just in poor taste and not particularly productive.
> If, generally, a prosecutor thinks that a person is not mentally stable enough to face trial for their crimes without commiting suicide, are they just allowed to get away with what they want?
Of course not, and this kind of question makes me feel like you're arguing in poor taste. Prosecutors have a ton of latitude in how they handle cases. Swartz was not some violent criminal who needed to be taught a lesson and be held up as an example to others. He was just a flawed human who believed scientific research (much of it funded by public, taxpayer money) shouldn't be locked up behind a corporation's paywall. The zeal in which this case was prosecuted far exceeded the "crime".
But in general, if a person is a suicide risk during any kind of court proceeding, yes, actions should be taken to ensure that they won't (or aren't able to) commit suicide. If that means being put in a hospital under observation, sure, though that extreme may not have been necessary to save Swartz. We have an obligation as a society to treat everyone with respect and care, even -- especially -- those we've accused of crimes. We're very far off from that ideal, of course.
- xadhominemx 5y ago> I consider the state of my mental health to be pretty solidly strong, but if I was facing an overzealous prosecutor telling me (convincingly) I was certainly going to jail for a very long time, I might take my own life. Aaron was offered a 6 month sentence in a low security facility