3 ms·
There's no censorship here. A large account broke their contract with a service provider, who is now choosing to suspend (not terminate) their account in respon
by smoldesu 5y ago
There's no censorship here. A large account broke their contract with a service provider, who is now choosing to suspend (not terminate) their account in response. Seems like a perfectly free and legal exchange to me.
- trempisacent 5y agoIt's still censorship. The point here is the risk of our social communications being concentrated via a few large companies, who have ended up with an enormous amount of power to control speech online globally.
- smoldesu 5y agoThen don't use those companies. Problem solved. There's plenty of decentralized and federated platforms that are perfect for people worried about being censored, same as it ever was. If you're too ignorant to use those platforms, I'm not taking pity on you.
- lostapathy 5y agoIf I make a post somewhere that there’s, comparatively, a tiny fraction of the audience of the main platforms, is that really a valid alternative?
- smoldesu 5y agoI'd argue it doesn't matter. If Taco Bell kicks you out of their store for breaking the rules, you can't sue them because the taco stand down the road isn't a "valid alternative". There were rules of engagement, and you broke them. Since you are the person who violated the contract, you're objectively the guilty party: the extent to which Facebook can punish you is only limited by how invested you are in the platform.
- the_snooze 5y agoWhy wouldn't it be a valid alternative? There's nothing stopping the audience from seeing your content off-platform if they so wish. Unless you want to make the claim that speakers are entitled to audiences, that is.
- lostapathy 5y agoIf the point of speaking in public is to be heard, speaking in front of no audience isn't really speaking. I'm not arguing you're entitle to an audience, either, just that taking your speech from a major player to a much smaller niche player is not nearly equivalent.
- the_snooze 5y agoThe cost of going to a website other than Facebook is literally zero. People do it all the time. The only impediment is the audience's own will and awareness. And they're still free to publicize non-Facebook websites on Facebook. If someone's off-Facebook site flops, that's their fault. Tons of non-Facebook communities have vibrant conversations between multiple speakers and audiences. This site is one. Maybe I'm just dense, but I'm not seeing the cost differential, either for the speaker or audience. What Facebook is doing is equivalent to saying "you don't have to go home, but you can't stay here." What's so wrong about that?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- trempisacent 5y agoProblem not solved. The issue here is the huge amount of power to control online speech that these few companies have gained, with basically no oversight. Suggesting that people who don't like it should just use something else, doesn't actually address this issue.
- x86_64Ubuntu 5y agoHe's not censored. He had a blog that no one visited and it went away. He has plenty of outlets to disseminate his message.
- smoldesu 5y agoExactly. Nobody here limited his right to free speech when every official Government outlet was still perfectly operational, alongside his personal website and presence on decentralized platforms. Sounds like someone's mad that nobody wants to listen to them...
- Caprinicus 5y agoYes, a free and legal exchange that meets the definition of censorship. Many famous censorship schemes operate entirely in the private sphere. The Hays code, for instance, censored movies for decades and existed purely in contracts between movie distributors.
- tshaddox 5y agoThe Hays code might not be the best example, since it was "self-censorship" but done in direct response to imminent threats of government censorship all over the United States. Several states had just created censorship boards in response to a Supreme Court ruling which declared that freedom of speech didn't apply to movies.
- waterhouse 5y agoThat might actually make it a good example, if Greenwald is right here: https://greenwald.substack.com/p/congress-escalates-pressure-on-tech https://greenwald.substack.com/p/congress-escalates-pressure...
- tshaddox 5y agoBut again, it’s weird to see this painted in partisan terms. How short is our memory? I would have sworn just last year that those tech companies were painted as strict censors of right-wing content who needed to be strongly regulated. Apparently now it has switched again? But of course this is just partisans playing the victim (at least until someone can show evidence of some actual partisan bias in their censorship/moderation).
- xdennis 5y agoYes, those are exactly the words that will be used when leftists will be censored as well.
- smoldesu 5y agoThere's no "left" or "right" in EULA enforcement, just objectionable content and non-objectionable content. If you don't agree with their rulings, then you shouldn't sign up for an account. Twitter and Facebook are not platforms to run a Government from, and they've repeatedly made that perfectly clear. Your discourse is liable to be removed at any time, because it's not your bar. They can kick you out at any time, because you're there on the graces of the collective establishment. Dystopian? Maybe, but that's what happens when a libertarian platform invites capitalism to run wild.
- wyager 5y ago“There’s no censorship here. It’s actually <insert long-winded definition of censorship.>” Just because something is legal doesn’t mean it’s not censorship.