6 ms·
> Americans also spend way more water and fertilizer on their lawns than farmers use to grow corn, soybeans and other crops, according to the study. I have no
by sokoloff 5y ago
> Americans also spend way more water and fertilizer on their lawns than farmers use to grow corn, soybeans and other crops, according to the study.
I have no idea where that study's data came from. Corn needs about 250 pounds of nitrogen per acre per year. Soybeans are higher at 300-325 pounds/acre/crop.
Grass needs (on the high side) around 45# of nitrogen per acre per month only while actively growing. For a 6 month growing season (longer than mine is), that's only equal to corn, not "way more". Any homeowner who is using "way more" than that is going to get terrible (and self-correcting) results.
- kickout 5y agoThis is highly misinformed. Corn doesn't 'need' any supplemental fertilizer (and was grown without much for centuries), we choose to do it because it's more profitable. Soybeans, being a legume, make their own nitrogen. So you comment is wildly misleading making people believe people are putting 300 pounds of nitrogen per acre
- sokoloff 5y ago"Needs" might be slightly too strong a word in terms of supplemental nitrogen for corn, but note that the corn is going to take nitrogen either way, whether naturally provided or supplemented. (Corn is a grass with very tasty seeds.) However, when the article makes comparisons to what farmers are actually doing, I think it's fair game to bring in data around what farmers are actually doing.
- kickout 5y agoNo farmer is applying nitrogen to soybeans. They fix their own nitrogen, and generally add nitrogen to the system. Any plant is going to take nutrients (native or otherwise) from the system. Just because ornamental species don't have a commercial value doesn't mean they aren't extracting nutrients I am very familiar with corn being a grass. Although its seed are very much not tasty unless they happen to have a well known sucrose mutation.
- sokoloff 5y ago> No farmer is applying nitrogen to soybeans. Incorrect. https://nutrien-ekonomics.com/news/do-high-yielding-soybeans-need-supplemental-nitrogen/ https://nutrien-ekonomics.com/news/do-high-yielding-soybeans...
- bluGill 5y agoWhat farmers apply is generally closer to what is actually needed for the crops - often guided by soil samples. Not doing that means throwing away a lot of money. Homeowners often put down way more chemical than is needed. Its economics, a single homeowner putting in twice the fertilizer as needed is still spending less than $100 so they don't really care - but over a farm putting twice what is needed down costs thousands of dollars that could be spent on something else the farmer wants. Farmers are also a lot more concerned about their fertilizer getting into the plants and no running off. Sure a lot does run off anyway, but that is wasted money so they are interested in anything that will keep it on their fields.