7 ms·
Divisive Covid ‘lab leak’ debate prompts dire warnings from researchers
- aritmo 5y agoDelusional Trump is now claiming $10T from China. The "debate" over a leak looks more like a ruse and an attack to China than anything.
- the_third_wave 5y agoTrump derangement syndrome like this has been a large factor in the delay of real studies into the origin of the pandemic and has given the Chinese leadership enough time to make it unlikely that definite proof can still be found should the virus have escaped from a lab in Wuhan - something which seems more likely than not given the circumstantial evidence available. Also, Trump has been out of power for almost half a year now, it is time to let him go. Look at the current leadership in the White House and make sure to hold them to the same standards as you did the previous government - an even more strict standard really since the corporate press has dropped the ball completely on that front.
- space_rock 5y agoWho really knows the details? It's very difficult to get reliable information from the CCP and they have already been caught trying to cover things up. My guess is no one really knows outside of China and the people claiming to know either way are lying
- totalZero 5y agoThe problem, as I see it stated in the article and elsewhere, is that people who suggest a serious investigation so that we can "know the details" are promptly shouted down by certain elements of the Western media. Meanwhile, China's ruling Communist Party is pushing a theory that the virus arrived on frozen food imports.
- underseacables 5y agoYou mean it wasn’t from a US military operation, as the Chinese government was claiming?
- Proven 5y agoDivisive? How? And what's wrong with divisive debates? Do we need more Faucism? Let the people see whatever evidence hasn't been destroyed and make up their mind. I don't need a government Czar to make informed conclusions.
- Darmody 5y agoThat kind of reasoning is very common today. Don't talk about that or don't question the conclusion we came up to because it could create some discomfort. Very similar to fascism/authoritarianism but with beautiful words.
- totalZero 5y agoWe need effective planners to make public health decisions. If you can cough on me and indirectly kill my elderly parents, then you should be subject to some kind of government regulation. We ought to use experts to help establish and modulate those rules. I honestly believe that Fauci did a great service to his country and it was a capstone in his truly productive career. It's OK to appreciate good work. Think about his work environment, the risks involved, and the pace at which all the facts were unfolding. It is our good fortune that someone with deep subject knowledge and skill at communication was available at all. Don't take this as an argument against your main point. I agree that we should have the guts to engage with good faith in divisive debates. The "good faith" part is important because it keeps us united as people despite the potential immiscibility of our ideas.
- fallingfrog 5y agoIf I was the president and I knew it was a lab leak, I would probably yell at Xi Xinping in private but then claim it was a bat in public. To allow them to save face. In fact let’s game this out: Option 1) say it was a bat Option 2) say it was a lab leak If option 2, then xinping has to either acknowledge and apologize, or deny it. Option 1) acknowledge it. But then he gets removed as leader since the Chinese people will see him as weak. Option 2) deny it. This is what he would do. If he denies it, then probably the USA will apply some kind of sanctions on China, which again stirs up tensions. But China can’t do anything about it because of US military superiority. So how does that end? China is humiliated at having sanctions and in their view, false accusations leveled against them. They respond with a huge arms buildup and this results in a reciprocal buildup in the USA. Better to just let them save face. Edit: I’m not saying that I am going to lie about this. I’m not the president and this is all hypothetical musing. More to the point I don’t know if it really was a bat or if it was actually a lab leak. I’m just trying to imagine what the president might possibly be thinking right now.
- dTal 5y agoIt's dangerous to engage in higher-order thinking, lest you fail to achieve the highest order: First-order: "The evidence points to a lab leak." Second-order: "We can't say it's a lab leak, it'll cause mayhem. Let's say it was a bat." Third-order: "We can't lie to people about something this important. When the truth comes out eventually, it'll be mayhem squared and they won't trust us next time."
- corty 5y agoYour Third-order fails to account for the passage of time: When the truth comes out, enough time will have passed and the current leadership will be the former leadership. The next generation of leaders will vow to be better and carry on, saving face. See Gulf of Tonkin, first and second Iraq-US-war, etc. I think the conclusion will always be to lie to the public, because the higher-order-effects almost always have long delays.
- totalZero 5y agoNah. You should tell the truth on this topic, not only for normative reasons but also because it's going to come out anyway. The whole world is watching this virus. The next hegemonic rivalry in the world is already unfolding between China and the USA, and much of its battleground is found in the third world. Those countries are all evaluating the costs and benefits of aligning with China versus aligning with the United States. China and the USA are going to build up arms anyway, so why tell lies that benefit China?
- silicon2401 5y agoLeadership and researchers have already destroyed their credibility by repeatedly lying to the public about their intentions. Last year they consciously lied that masks were ineffective to preserve them for health workers. This year they lied about the motivation for dropping mask mandates: it was to motivate vaccination, not because it was just a new scientific finding. Not to mention the failure to acknowledge Taiwan as its own country to appease the CCP. The only rational argument is to not conclude anything unless solid evidence emerges. Anybody who wants you to conclude something prematurely is pushing an agenda
- MrBuddyCasino 5y ago> Leadership and researchers have already destroyed their credibility by repeatedly lying to the public about their intentions. Published March 18, before the obvious became mainstream consensus: "Covid is science's Chernobyl" https://graymirror.substack.com/p/covid-is-sciences-chernobyl https://graymirror.substack.com/p/covid-is-sciences-chernoby...
- FridayoLeary 5y agoBut they seem to be blissfully unaware of this. My respect for my governments covid guidelines is quite... low. There's a limit to how many lies, policy reversals and guesswork i'm willing to swallow. And it was at least 85% guesswork in the early stages. The "experts" were clueless!
- loopz 5y agoWhat could you expect, it was a new virus strain not previously seen. There were mixed and missing reports from China, and requirement to act fast on something unknown not previously seen before. Leadership didn't melt everywhere though. In smaller regions, response could quickly meet the challenge and did so phenomenally in several places. Also in regions with mixed ownership of media, reporting were pretty nuanced too.
- FridayoLeary 5y agoI expected them to confess their ignorance more honestly. Which they didn't.
- CodeWriter23 5y agoImagine being a scientist and advocating the position that the truth should not be sought in order to protect people’s feelings.
- Fricken 5y agoIt may hurt your feelings to know this, but The investigation isn't scientifically important. It is motivated by politics. Gotta find a way to finger China.
- dclusin 5y agoYes because discussions about safety protocols at laboratories like these aren't worth having or trying to improve.
- Fricken 5y agoNo, because the investigation isn't motivated by that, obviously. You're being deliberately disingenuous, because it isn't science you're interested in. You're interested in fingering China.
- dang 5y agoYou can't break the site guidelines like this, regardless of how wrong another is or you feel they are. We ban accounts that do it, and we've had to warn you more than once in the past. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and sticking to the rules when posting here, we'd be grateful. I realize it's not easy when it feels like you're in a minority position, but actually it isn't easy to begin with, and we all need to make the effort.
- notacoward 5y agoAre you in turn assuming that those discussions aren't happening already? It seems like you are, and thus your sarcasm is ill warranted.
- rockmartin 5y agoThe whole thing was a setup to get people to vaccinate. mRNA delivery is too new to understand long term effects.
- rockmartin 5y agoLab leak is just another step in the narrative. Covid was likely a bio weapon released to put fear in people so they would vaccinate.
- underseacables 5y agoScientists should never be afraid to speak to truth and speak their mind. Whether it’s a lab leak, gender, or climate change, scientific fact should be immune to political comfort.
- jacknews 5y ago"some scientists have put forward unsubstantiated claims linking the coronavirus to the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV)," Indeed, but zoonotic origin is also unsubstantiated at this point. In fact this itself is surprising, since in most other cases, with far fewer resources dedicated to the search, the origins are reliably indicated fairly quickly. So it's a case of balance of probability, based on circumstantial evidence. Demands to investigate a potential lab leak more fully may well be politically uncomfortable, 'unhelpful' in ending the pandemic, etc, etc, but should be made anyway to get to the truth. That is what science is about, after all. Perhaps some virologists complain too much.
- tzs 5y ago> Indeed, but zoonotic origin is also unsubstantiated at this point. In fact this itself is surprising, since in most other cases, with far fewer resources dedicated to the search, the origins are reliably indicated fairly quickly. It took five years for SARS. The origin of the 2013 Ebola outbreak is still unknown. Years to never is the norm for tracing the origins of new viruses. Even for known viruses where we already know what species it lives in normally it usually takes years to find where a particular major outbreak started. It took until 2016 to find out where, other than "probably somewhere in Mexico", that the H1N1 strain that gave us the 2009 swine flu pandemic came from.
- jacknews 5y agoBut progress was made in months on eg SARS1 and MERS, identifying intermediary species, etc. What do we have for COVID19? Nothing at all. After more than a year of surely much more intense search.
- bookofsand 5y ago"Lab leak" and "zoonotic" are not mutually exclusive. The pandemic could have been triggered by simply collecting samples from a remote cave and culturing them in a lab in the middle of a 10M people metropolis. A routine lab accident then led to the uncontrolled replication of the virus. Similarly, uranium sitting in the ground at low density is largely inoffensive, but increase its density up to the critical point and you end up with an uncontrolled chain reaction. Fundamental question: Under which circumstances is it ethical to culture dangerous viruses in a lab? This is obviously a conversation that some influential virology researchers don't want to have, therefore the disgraceful political circus created to deflect it.
- bcatanzaro 5y agoOf course virologists would play down the lab leak hypothesis. They are the ones doing controversial research to make Coronaviruses more infectious. They would like the public not to pay attention to the dangers of their work, but to keep funding it. Nature should put the conflict of interest front and center in any discussion fo this kind.
- zadkey 5y agoYeah I have heard both sides of the debate. Strongest argument for lab leak seems to sourced here: https://nicholaswade.medium.com/origin-of-covid-following-the-clues-6f03564c038 https://nicholaswade.medium.com/origin-of-covid-following-th...
- dazsnow 5y agoAmericans are so desperate for the narrative they've been conditioned to believe is true.
- foolzcrow 5y agoFacebook and twitter officially banned scientific debate. So we all better ask them what the "truth" is or we will get in trouble. King Zuck will be mad we even had this convo on here.
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.is/xPBEF https://archive.is/xPBEF