3 ms·
There's a long industry history of stealing code, but I'm surprised to hear this story of Sun allegedly doing it. My impression is that reason for the stealing
by neilv 5y ago
There's a long industry history of stealing code, but I'm surprised to hear this story of Sun allegedly doing it.
My impression is that reason for the stealing usually makes sense. For example, a key library that's hard to write that's just copied into the source tree, ignoring licensing. Or an appliance developer didn't want to deal with licensing for Linux or BusyBox. Or an individual developer in over their head quietly copies code.
The time I heard an explainable incident happened with my code, was in mid/late-'90s. An acquaintance, who'd offered to be one of the testers for an unreleased Java desktop application I wrote, then reportedly ran it through a decompiler, and passed it off as his own code, in a demo to investors. He later acknowledged doing this, and said he'd send me a Sun (ha) workstation as compensation. I declined.
Then there are incidents for which the reason isn't obvious, like the one from the article. I speculate that sometimes the explanation might simply be that the perpetrator wasn't quite right in the head at the time, like in some famous cases of journalism fabrication.
An inexplicable one involving my code was when an open source developer took a substantial and novel package that I wrote, stripped out my name and license notices, including out of the main file, and posted the package with themself identified as the author. There were also a couple other incidents with that person that seemed like that hadn't yet learned how to play well with others, in engineering or open source. I asked a mutual acquaintance, in confidence, what was going on with that person. The acquaintance checked, and was also baffled. In that case, I suppose that maybe the perpetrator was going through a difficult time, and not thinking clearly. Or maybe it was a combination of unlikely accidents that looked worse than the intent was (which happens).
In the article's story of the Sun incident, I'm a little surprised that (speculating) an engineer could do this despite all the other people in engineering who might be in a position to notice something funny going on. And Sun had been the dot in some dotcoms by 2005, so presumably they had some strong engineering processes around what goes into product.
Maybe the demo was something put together by a systems engineer, working as part of a small marketing/sales team, rather than under an engineering organization, so a lot fewer engineers were aware of it?
- toyg 5y agoYou are very compassionate towards people just literally stealing code. My experience is that a lot of folks just don't care about licenses: they steal and rebrand by any mean necessary, I guess to accumulate reputation. I wrote a few silly scripts in my lifetime, all small-time stuff (so trivial it never got me hired as a Dev anywhere). No matter whether I marked things as GPL or BSS, I often found them copied on GitHub with my copyright notices stripped. In the case of the BSD license, that's literally the only thing you can't do! In some cases it was utterly blatant: cloning from my own GitHub repo and then replacing authorship notices in the very first commit. I mean, come on guys, at least try to be smart; you can add your name just fine... When I politely asked to, y'know, respect license terms and reinstate the notices, some people just took down their repo rather than doing that. I bet they then re-uploaded it somewhere else.
- brendangregg 5y agoI've seen blatant cases as well. There was a github repo where someone was sharing their notes on performance engineering, and there were tickets from people thanking them for their amazing work. Except these notes were literally copy-n-pasted pages from my systems performance book. It's weird to find all these messages from people thanking someone else for the work I did. When I contacted them to ask how they thought it was ok to republish my work like this (I was giving them a chance to explain), they just took it all down.