2 ms·
Where does this expectation come from that a rich organization or person using open source software should be paying for it? That’s against the entire spirit of
by kortilla 5y ago
Where does this expectation come from that a rich organization or person using open source software should be paying for it? That’s against the entire spirit of the open source license in the first place.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoFrom the same place taxes come, or more generally, quite a lot of social obligations. It's the expectation that, if you're benefiting from commons, you should also contribute something back to the commons. A company using open source software to make money is making money off commons. Makes sense they should feel obliged to contribute something back, and since they have the surplus of the best form of contribution - money - it's reasonable to expect them to donate some of it.
- kortilla 5y agoOpen source isn’t a commons. That’s your major mistake. Using it does not deprive others or wear down something. > it's reasonable to expect them to donate some of it. No, that’s actually quite ridiculous. “Reasonable” implies some level of reasoning behind it. There is no “reasonable” proposal of how much money should be given when it’s against the very spirit of the license to expect payment based on usage. What is the percentage amount of profit an individual or corporation should contribute? Give me a concrete calculation of software usage and how much should go back to the project. Is it measured in percentage of clock cycles spent executing that code across all of an entity’s compute? Presumably the IRS should also give a cut of all tax revenue collected by the US to the open source projects it uses too, right? If not, your beef seems to be purely with private enterprise being successful more than any fairness based billing.