9 ms·
While some of the "hacking" was no more than calling into voicemail accounts with no pin/password set (though most instances would have involved at least caller
by dspillett 15y ago
While some of the "hacking" was no more than calling into voicemail accounts with no pin/password set (though most instances would have involved at least caller-id spoofing), it will hopefully (yeah, right, says the cynic in me) make the tabloid rags more careful about overstepping their bounds in future.
The scandal, which blew up massively again after evidence was presented of them interfering with a missing-persons/murder enquiry and has only got worse after evidence that the families of bombing victims and those injured/killed in overseas conflicts were also subject to similar invasion of privacy, has caused significant activity in government and a large amount of embarrassment for News International - possibly to the point of threatening their attempt to buy the rest of Sky.
I wonder how many more phone and email hacking/monitoring scandals, involving the media or other organisations, will drop out of the woodwork following (or during the investigation of) this one...
edit: removed the quotes from "news"paper in the title. A tad hypocritical of me to editorialise like that while taking shots at a tabloid!
- ceejayoz 15y ago> While some of the "hacking" was no more than calling into voicemail accounts with no pin/password set... Taking stuff from my house is still robbery even if I left the front door open.
- corin_ 15y agoI think (assume) he wasn't questioning the link between what they did with illegality/immorality, just that "hacking" implies something a little more technical.
- dspillett 15y agoAye. The difference between taking a laptop left on a train and breaking into a house to take one. No less theft in either case, but one takes (a little at least) more effort than the other and is less dependent on carelessness on the part of the victim.
- goatforce5 15y agoTake a laptop left on the train isn't a very good analogy. The train is essentially a public space (for anyone holding a ticket, at least) and people have a right to be there. Getting in to PIN-less voicemail boxes is like walking down a street and checking which doors are unlocked, and then assuming a lack of security means the owner is permitting you to take whatever you can find inside.
- EliRivers 15y agoOnly if it uses violence or the threat thereof; otherwise, it's theft.
- speckledjim 15y agoNot a great analogy. Nothing was taken. It would be more accurate to say that you left your curtains open, and someone took a picture of the inside of your house through the windows. Maybe an invasion of privacy, but not theft.
- tptacek 15y agoThis is totally besides the point. He was simply responding to the notion that the ease of the act mitigated the severity.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- pavel_lishin 15y ago> It would be more accurate to say that you left your curtains open, and someone took a picture of the inside of your house through the windows. And if I was naked at the time, and if they then sold those pictures of me, I'm fairly certain it would be a crime.
- speckledjim 15y agoI didn't say it was legal, I just said it was a bad analogy. If you setup a directory /admin on your webserver, and forget to password protect it, and someone accesses it, you can't really call it hacking.
- pak 15y agoThat's still a bad analogy, and you've used it way too many times in this thread. Whether or not accessing anything on a webserver is illegal depends partly on your intentions while doing so. That's a basic function of most court trials--to discern your intentions. For example, see the differences between the various degrees of murder, and the way such trials often hinge on "preconceived intent." If my intention in accessing "/admin" was to access your server without your authorization to access some protected piece of information, damage computers, or defraud you, that may indeed be a crime. See http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/18/1030.html http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/18/1030.html . It doesn't matter whether it was password protected or not. If I went there by accident, however, it probably was not a crime, although depending on what I accessed I may wind up having to go to court to prove that my intentions were benign.
- onedognight 15y agoI think his point was not it didn't rise to the legal definition of hacking (of course it did), but whether it rose to the Hacker News definition of newsworthy hacking (hardly).
- tptacek 15y agoNot that you said otherwise, but for what it's worth: accessing someone else's voice mail is no less a crime if they don't have a PIN set. A lot of nerds are under the very faulty impression that the severity of "hacking" crimes scales with the difficulty of the attack. No. It has nothing whatsoever to do with how hard these things are to pull off.
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoIn physical 'hacking' if you don't make any effort to secure your valuables, you can't claim they were stolen. I wonder why it is different with virtual valuables?
- Maascamp 15y agoThat's just wrong. So if I leave the door to my house unlocked and you walk in and take my stuff it wouldn't be stealing?
- speckledjim 15y agoNothing was taken. It would be more like "I leave my front door open, and you walk in and take a photograph".
- dpark 15y agoThat's also not legal. You can't simply walk into someone's house, regardless of whether it's locked. It's unlawful trespass, it's a gross violation of privacy (especially since you took a picture), and it may be legally deemed breaking and entering, burglary, or some other felony depending on jurisdiction. Also, I believe that the voicemail "hackers" also deleted some voicemails, and in that case something was indeed taken.
- JoeAltmaier 15y agoI don't think the analogies are doing justice. Nobody's house, not even a virtual one, was involved. An open-to-the-public voicemail system was used. The 'victim' was sympathetic and folks reacted emotionally. Its not clear to me this was espionage, or even a misdemeanor.
- JonnieCache 15y agoDont forget all the stuff about helping people under suspicion of murder spy on the police officer investigting them! And extensive bribing of high level police officers! Oh yeah and all the links these people had right to the highest level of our government. WRT more scandals: every newspaper does this. It is standard industry practice. Why do you think they never gave notw a hard time over it, all these years? The same reason political parties never attack each other over funding. Because they all stink.
- dspillett 15y ago> WRT more scandals: every newspaper does this. It is standard industry practice. Which is one of the reasons we might see a few more scandals become public, either because people in the know see the opportunity to milk a few quid out of the momentum built up by the current publicity or because people currently getting the sack don't want to go down without taking a few rivals out on the way. Or, less cynically, just because any public investigation (one of which is promised by the government) into NoTW uncovers significant evidence of the wider issue.
- mturmon 15y agoAccording to the NYT article summarizing this, the reporters (or PIs hired by them) not only accessed messages in the murder case, they also deleted some to make room for more. Assuming this is true, it makes irrelevant a lot of gedanken experiments in the thread here.