9 ms·
Kevin Drum had a good summary of this a couple of weeks ago, much shorter. His take? There's no more evidence for the lab leak theory now than there was a year
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
Kevin Drum had a good summary of this a couple of weeks ago, much shorter. His take? There's no more evidence for the lab leak theory now than there was a year ago, BUT what has changed is that the cross-over theory implied that we would find certain evidence for the vectors, and that evidence has not shown up. KD's take was that it's not so much that the lab leak theory has become more likely, it's the that biological origin theory has become less likely.
- 542458 5y agoWe’ve been trying to find the zoonotic origin of Ebola for decades without any success. We don’t have anywhere near a complete catalog of animal diseases, and of those only a fraction have been sequenced.
- kaesar14 5y agoWe didn’t have the same confluence of other circumstantial evidence we do in this case. There’s no good reason to think Ebola came from a lab.
- lawnchair_larry 5y agoHaha. No. It’s because of politics and TDS. People were taught that this was a Trump theory. That’s all the media needs to say to ensure that nobody will take it seriously and nobody will tolerate anyone else who takes it seriously.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoExcept that it was a Trump theory. That doesn't mean it cannot be true. It does mean that after 3 years and several thousand fully documented outright lies, the presumption of truth was no longer being granted.
- fragileone 5y agoExcept he was proven right yet again that social media and old media orgs will censor others and lie to the public when it fits their political agenda.
- kaesar14 5y agoRight - instead of trying to debate the veracity of the argument, it was immediately cast as a political battle, and being on the same side as Trump in most urban and most media circles was asking to be ostracized. It’s absolutely poisonous.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoHow as anybody going to "debate the veracity of the argument"? What information was anybody going to use? Even so, in the intervening period, even when Trump was still president, several US agency reports concluded that the virus likely did not originate from a lab, and one assumes that they had more information than anybody else.
- willcipriano 5y ago>What information was anybody going to use? I used these three pieces of evidence to come to this conclusion for myself last year. 1. Wuhan is the epicenter of the outbreak. 2. Wuhan has a lab that works with bat covid. 3. China initally tooks steps to hide the virus from the world until that was no longer possible. >several US agency reports concluded that the virus likely did not originate from a lab. Keep that in mind next time.
- onetimeusename 5y agoI think the release that three scientists fell ill in November 2019, who were working on gain of function research at the Wuhan lab with Covid-like symptoms, may have made the lab leak theory more probable, at least in my opinion, since a year ago. Note that doesn't say they definitely had Covid or that anything conclusive about the theory was settled. Did Kevin Drum say otherwise?