4 ms·
Let's look at the chain of events. Computing machinery becomes exponentially cheaper, and it gets pushed into all corners of industry. Shared computing becomes
by mikewarot 5y ago
Let's look at the chain of events. Computing machinery becomes exponentially cheaper, and it gets pushed into all corners of industry.
Shared computing becomes a thing, and the need to have a better model of security is realized as a lesson from Viet Nam, and the Capability Based Security model is born.
Microprocessors again exponentially decrease the cost of computing, and Capability Based Security isn't required because all of the installations tend to have one or a handful of users.
The internet is born, and the cost of networking becomes exponentially cheaper, now all of those low security end users are connected together.
Systems become more powerful with the continuing drop in the cost of processor, memory and storage, so they become more complex. Nobody writes their own software any more, almost all coding is outsourced in some fashion. Security is only a concern if it trickles back to the original source as a problem.
A culture of "move fast and break things" pervades Silicon Valley, and the internet, and thus newer is always seen as better.
The lack of a security model at the base of all these systems is exploited for financial gain. Band-aid layers are added to try to patch the obviously inferior operating systems that pervade the land.
Because the lessons of capability based security were ignored for decades, and not taught, the common consensus is that computers can never be made secure, and your best hope is to hire the smartest people in the world, at less than the average market rate, to secure your systems.
And we repeatedly blame criminals, corporations, programmers, users, and now other countries, instead of solving the problem by properly implementing security.
- cyrrus 5y agoAs someone who isn’t a security expert, If you had a magic wand, what does this future look like to you? What is properly implemented security?
- Karrot_Kream 5y ago> Because the lessons of capability based security were ignored for decades, and not taught, the common consensus is that computers can never be made secure, and your best hope is to hire the smartest people in the world, at less than the average market rate, to secure your systems. I presume the OP is a fan of capability-security and while I'm not an expert on capabilities, I agree they can go a _long_ way to mitigating risk. Unfortunately, none of the mainstream OSs even offer a smidge of a way of actually working with capabilities. Google's recently laughed Fuschia _does_ support capabilities out of the box, but they have a long way to go before they're regarded as mainstream.
- mikewarot 5y agoYes, I am a long time (2005) fan of Capability Based Security. Yes, Fuschia and Genode both have a way to go before they are good enough for general purpose use.
- FpUser 5y agoIf under "proper security" the author means something that is impenetrable then such thing does not and will never exist in general. We can approach some reasonable level but with the current explosion of software, its complexity, insane degree of dependency, every button of your shirt becoming "smart" gizmo connected to Amazon and whatnot I believe the situation for now will only get worse.
- mikewarot 5y agoIf I had a magic wand: I'm not a "security expert", I have no encyclopedic knowledge of the ways of criminals. Let's agree that is well established. I do know how computers work, down to the transistor level. I've been playing with them since 1978. Rules I would impose: Industrial control systems would be isolated from the internet by a unidirectional network. Data could get out, ONLY. You can have helpers on the inside and outside to handle things like buffering logs, etc. If you need remote control of something industrial, it has to be on a physically separate network, airgapped from the world. In Government, I would have NEVER connected the Office of Personnel Management system to the internet, except to allow data INBOUND through a data diode. All outbound queries would require passing through a human with the proper security clearance. All sensitive or classified systems would be similarly isolated, and only allow ingress of data. Multilevel secure computing would be required for all government systems. Red Teams would be used to test security periodically, run by the Inspector General. Capability Based Security would be the norm. Most users wouldn't see much of a difference in their day to day interactions. Bug bounties would be required for any commercial software vendor, with public disclosure after 1 year of all payouts. Bugs submitted that aren't paid would be disclosed in 6 months. The NSA would shift roles from spying on everything just because they can, to first making sure nobody can spy on us, and only then spying on everyone else. Also: Email would require authentication on send Null terminated strings would be abolished Broadband would be nationalized and free to all
- mikewarot 5y agoOther thread: I don't have a magic wand Things will continue to get worse. Google's Fuchsia and Genode are two capability based Operating Systems that are likely to be good enough to hack in the next year or so. I expect 3-5 more years of this before enough experience is gained with Capability Based systems to finally cause mass adoption. In the meanwhile, it would be nice to have a Raspberry Pi based data diode setup that can buffer all the standard stuff, as well as SCADA. Also in the meanwhile, there is non-zero danger that Congress will use this as an excuse to purge the nation of general purpose computing available to the masses. Also, the Military Industrial Complex will push for more funds from this. Also, many a Startup will sell more security snake-oil.
- Karrot_Kream 5y ago> I expect 3-5 more years of this before enough experience is gained with Capability Based systems to finally cause mass adoption. And distributed systems, at least for the web, are _finally_ starting to put capabilities in place. Embedded is a different world sadly.
- onethought 5y agoThe irony of this post on a VC hosted forum. If you believe this, couldn’t/shouldn’t you pitch it get funding and live the Silicon Valley dream and “make the world a better place”?
- mikewarot 5y agoThe profit is in treatments, not cures. If I were going to pitch something, it would be a kit consisting of 2 servers and a data diode, useful for getting data to move only in your direction of choice, guaranteed by the laws of physics to be un-hackable. (LED/Photodetector pair)