4 ms·
I don't think these statements are necessarily wrong, but I might push back a bit. On a smaller team, hiring high performers is obviously important. But for la
by legitster 5y ago
I don't think these statements are necessarily wrong, but I might push back a bit.
On a smaller team, hiring high performers is obviously important. But for large organizations, there is a WIDE tolerance for incompetence. Hiring staff consistently underestimate how much can be learned on the job. Mid-managers are much, much more easily replaced than anyone wants to admit - and if you are already hiring lifestyle employees, you may as well be hiring a diverse set of project jockeys.
I won't go so far as to say merit is a myth, but adequately assessing merit at scale during a hiring process does feel pretty fraught.
- thegrimmest 5y agoI wouldn't say so. I've done a lot hiring for programming positions at various seniority levels. I've never found it hard to determine if a person can write code and communicate clearly about code written. It usually takes no more than a handful of specific questions and a 5-10min live coding exercise. I find 90%+ of candidates are unable to meet a basic standard. The candidate could have no video and obfuscated audio, and I'd still enthusiastically hire them if they fell into the 10%. Most people I've spoken to have the same experience. Programming is an employee's market and stands to be into the future. As such, I don't think anyone who can code is at a significant disadvantage.
- davidbanham 5y agoLive coding during an interview is a particularly stressful environment that bears little relation to the day to day work of building software. Have you considered that if 90% of your vetted applicants are failing your test that there might be something wrong with your methodology?
- stmfreak 5y agoNope. You can live code with very simple questions. Very simple. Then explore what they wrote and why. If they cannot build rapport and have a conversation with you, how are they going to build rapport and have conversations with the other coders on your team?
- thegrimmest 5y agoOne of my core expectations of candidates is the ability to talk dispassionately and in detail about the code they are writing. If they can't do that then I've found they don't make very good collaborators. Live coding is akin to pairing, which is a common practice.
- oceanghost 5y agoThis has always amazed me. I have found that competence+capability often have very little to do with reward+recognition. I think managers-- bad ones-- pigeonhole people and make decisions on personal preference. I once worked for a Fortune small cap-- and there was this incompetent manager (IM), nice guy-- assigned to the hardware portion of the project. There was this very competent manager (CM), assigned to the software portion. It was recognize by management that IM was running his half of the project into the ground-- but the management "liked" him, so they assigned all his work to the CM and then promoted IM so he was now CM's boss and didn't have to do the work he couldn't do. CM took on twice the workload and lead the project to success. The perverseness of this is staggering. IM is given more money to do nothing. CM has to do twice the work for the same amount of money. Later, the company tried to fire him for an injury he sustained on the job, claiming he was "no longer able to perform his job function."
- kthejoker2 5y agoIf you want any business done for you, you should ask a busy man to do it. - W.J. Kennedy, 1856 Or, less charitably, the Gervais Principle strikes again.
- SecurityMinded 5y agoMerit does not necessarily refer to "what you know" at the time of interview but it might also mean, "how capable you are to learn things you don't know" or "how suitable for the position in general you are". And that is absolutely correct. Travesty is, not hiring the perfect candidate but hiring an inferior worker because of his/her skin color, gender fluidity, religion or many other things associated with this person, none of which are relevant to the position offered. I could not agre more with this CEO.