4 ms·
> if we assume some other system takes care of documenting that the NFT was in fact created by the owner What other system are you talking about? I could deter
by tshaddox 5y ago
> if we assume some other system takes care of documenting that the NFT was in fact created by the owner
What other system are you talking about? I could determine that you control the NFT of a digital work by observing the artist's statement of issuance and your message demonstrating control of the NFT on the blockchain. Determining the validity of the artist's statement of issuance could be done using public-key cryptography. I fail to see what additional system is necessary.
- Drew_ 5y agoThe "additional system" would be your first qualifier for ownership > observing the artist's statement of issuance eg: having an authority affirm your ownership of something. The secondary system of using ownership of some piece of a blockchain is superfluous considering the first system is all you would need to prove ownership.
- tshaddox 5y agoBut the artist’s statement of issuance is not an additional system. I’m still not sure what other system you’re referring to.
- lottin 5y agoThe additional system is the trusted authority that is required to certify that the issuer is who they say they are and that they own the thing.
- tshaddox 5y agoAgain, there is no such trusted authority required when using technologies like public-key cryptography.
- TomSwirly 5y agoSo we're back to the original question: how do we know that the person writing the NFT owns the intellectual property?
- lottin 5y agoI repeat: "the trusted authority is required to certify that the issuer is who they say they are and that they own the thing." If you don't agree, please explain how a stranger's identity and ownership rights can be established using technologies like public-key cryptography without a trusted authority.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoSo if you're a famous artist, and I get your credentials and post my MS Paint doodles as NFTs, are these now original tshaddox's?
- tshaddox 5y agoNo, these would probably not be considered or valued as originals when the deception was revealed. No method of verification is perfect. You could also physically coerce the artist to issue an NFT. But this is not a unique “flaw” of NFTs. Art forgeries can also fool experts. People can steal physical items.
- spywaregorilla 5y agoSounds like you're describing an additional system.