3 ms·
You can also get a reproduction of a famous painting that is indistinguishable from the original to all but a small group of experts (and even experts might be
by tshaddox 5y ago
You can also get a reproduction of a famous painting that is indistinguishable from the original to all but a small group of experts (and even experts might be fooled by very skilled forgeries). If you just like how a painting looks, you can absolutely get the vast majority (perhaps even the entirety) of the aesthetic value of it from a (relatively) inexpensive reproduction. Yet the vast majority of the immense value of very famous paintings comes from originality, as determined by a small group of experts which the rest of us trust. This is not so unlike how NFTs work.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoWhile I agree with what you've written, this sentence, "This is not so unlike how NFTs work", is the critical point that remains to be seen. My opinion is that it's unlike NFTs enough in the average human mind that the analogy falls over. Yes, pretty much all of the value in expensive works of art is in the provenance of the artwork, not the actual image. But the fact that that provenance is embodied in a non-copyable physical piece of art, versus a ledger in the literal ether that is just a piece of text that says "Yep, this person bought it", is a critical difference that I think is unbridgeable.
- tshaddox 5y ago> My opinion is that it's unlike NFTs enough in the average human mind that the analogy falls over. Absolutely, that remains to be seen, and I think we're very clearly in an NFT craze at the moment that is going to result in a lot of people putting money in and losing it. My argument is simply that it is not absurd to use an NFT to represent originality for a digital work and for collectors to value that originality more than digital copies, and in fact it's extremely similar to how the determination and valuation of originality already works for physical paintings. I do think that a lot of the actual financial activity going on with NFTs right now is absurd, but not fundamentally more absurd than much of the financial activity going on with most assets in the world! > But the fact that that provenance is embodied in a non-copyable physical piece of art, versus a ledger in the literal ether that is just a piece of text that says "Yep, this person bought it", is a critical difference that I think is unbridgeable. My prediction is that it won't be any less bridgeable than the notion that the amount of money you have in your bank account is actually just a tiny amount of digital information stored on a computer somewhere in your bank's computer closet. The bank isn't actually storing the physical cash that you deposited, and moreover, that physical cash doesn't even represent anything physical!
- faefox 5y agoI think this hits the nail on the head. My response to seeing "the" Mona Lisa is much different than seeing a reproduction of the same, no matter how faithful that reproduction may be. In a digital space where anything and everything can be losslessly duplicated ad infinitum that distinction simply doesn't exist.
- tshaddox 5y agoBut I'm presuming you're not an expert, and you just trusted that the museum was showing the original. What if they show a fake one, and the original is kept somewhere more secure? Or what if all experts are wrong, and the one we think is the original is not actually the original? Would learning that diminish your value of that viewing experience?
- diamond559 5y agoExcept physical art is copyable too, there are plenty of examples of people being tricked into buying forgeries of physical art. The whole debate is whether people trust these art "experts" who can be just as easily tricked over the trust of a "piece of text" on a blockchain. It's clearly not unbridgeable for some people or there wouldn't have been this huge boom in NFTs. Though it remains to be seen whether they'll remain a niche online collectible or become more mainstream but I think it's trending towards broader acceptance.
- fl0wenol 5y agoHere's where this analogy falls apart. The real value in having an authentic painting comes from the history of the piece, that it is the same canvas and pigments that were touched by the (famous/reclusive/dead) artist (or at least one of their assistants) The same could be said of any museum piece. There is a weight and responsibility attached to that physical item that is carried with it. With an NFT, the digital asset you hold can never convey anything tangible about the creative process and history of the work; it's not like owning that unveils the PSD file and Youtube livestream of the artist at work with their Cintiq. The stream of bits is the stream of bits. Everyone gets access to the same stream of bits, except one person gets to wear a special hat while they look at them. It's like you started with a print or reproduction of the masterwork, but on a new canvas. Like you're saying this is print #00001, and you get to have that specific one. Sort of. So really it's not at all the same.
- tshaddox 5y ago> With an NFT, the digital asset you hold can never convey anything tangible about the creative process and history of the work The artist issued the NFT.
- fl0wenol 5y agoThe artist can sell numbered prints too. What I'm saying is that NFT _itself_ does not embody any aspect of the creative process or context. With the exception of the fact the artists issued an NFT in the first place on such-and-such date, and that might mean something in the future when we look back on this topic.
- tshaddox 5y agoWhat if the artist issues the NFT during a live stream of the creation of the digital artwork? It seems odd to me that we would consider a physical painting to “embody” the creative process, but somehow the creative process of a digital painting is lost forever?
- 5y ago