6 ms·
The big thing that it is missing is to let me categorize my outgoing content, and let people only pick up what they want. The mechanism that I would suggest is
by btilly 15y ago
The big thing that it is missing is to let me categorize my outgoing content, and let people only pick up what they want.
The mechanism that I would suggest is to have what I'd call "public circles". These are circles that I have, that I can talk to, that anyone can join/leave. That way I can easily separate out content by type (eg technical, jokes, kid stories, etc), and not worry that pushing things out is drowning people in unwanted types of content.
You might say that I can just add people to circles that I manage. This is true, but it requires me to know who wants that content, and requires people who want it to know that they can ask me for it. Both are barriers to sharing information that I don't mind being public, but don't want to bore people who know me in different contexts.
You might also say that this is equivalent to a simple form of tagging. This is true, but I think that it would make for a simpler UI.
- seri 15y agoThat would effectively be like a Facebook Page, wouldn't it? Believe me, you won't enjoy the signal to noise ratio within these "public circles". I proprosed a different solution to the same problem, as explained here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2738084 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2738084 Edit: On second read, I think we do share the same concept, just different naming.
- btilly 15y agoYup, same concept, different naming. Yet another useful variation is the idea of a public circle which multiple people can share to, aka a mailing list. There are lots of use cases for that, but that's not the primary thing that I am missing on Google+ right now.
- Sayter 15y ago"Public Circle" variation = Facebook Groups.
- btilly 15y agoYup. There are a lot of variations on "circles" that can make sense in different contexts. I'm hoping that Google+ adds more. Currently I'm just categorizing people by how I know them. For instance if I know them through work, which job(s) did I work with them in?
- NinetyNine 15y agoI'm working on a very early stage startup to solve this exact problem. One of our main challenges though seems the hardest part of finding a solution is having a social graph to test with, or how to gain traction in the first place. Content algorithms inherently need a lot of participation.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Sayter 15y ago"Public Circle" concept = Facebook Page with Facebook Groups adding ability.
- joelhaus 15y agoThis sounds like thenextweb.com's implementation of RSS subscriptions. A modal window pops up when you click the RSS icon on the right; it says "Pick & Mix The Blogs You Want to Subscribe To". Is that similar to what you propose? I do like that. Looking forward trying all this stuff out. Hope they send more invites soon, they actually opened for about 30 minutes last midnight.
- dr_viral 15y agoFunny http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6-llwYjxv8Y http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6-llwYjxv8Y :)
- johnl 15y agoI would think businesses could use the "public circles" for event marketing and give Google an entry into display marketing.
- btilly 15y agoI hadn't thought of that, but you are right.