4 ms·
I think it's pretty clear from the proposal that the only relevant NFT for some piece of digital media would be the NFT created by the original copyright holder
by tshaddox 5y ago
I think it's pretty clear from the proposal that the only relevant NFT for some piece of digital media would be the NFT created by the original copyright holder of that piece of digital media. For example, Getty could issue NFTs for a particular stock photograph.
Obviously any random person could create an NFT and claim that it represents ownership of a particular stock photograph, but that's not really relevant or problematic. You could also create a traditional paper certificate of title for your neighbor's car too, but obviously no one would respect it (unless they were tricked, but that's against the law and the legal system would tend to respect that genuine certificate of title).
- boublepop 5y agoBrilliant! So what you are saying is that NFT’s are a good documentation of ownership… if we assume some other system takes care of documenting that the NFT was in fact created by the owner. So you know if we have some other system to track ownership.
- Raidion 5y agoFor a lot of stuff that's really not a hard problem. You just create the NFT of the hash before publicly releasing the item, it's only for stuff that exists out there in the world already that's a problem. Doesn't mean it's not a good way to resolve stuff going forward. Biggest problem with NFTs are how they integrate with the existing legal frameworks of copyright, etc.
- chime 5y agoIf Getty signs an asset saying chime bought it at 'getty.com', that's proof enough. If I buy it at totally-legit-stock-photos.example.com, then it's on me to resolve the matter with Getty when they say my NFT is invalid. Getty's crawlers can still go around the web looking for stolen images. But if the images have a signature from a different vendor, then instead of just going after the gullible users, they can go after the signers. And if the images do not have any signatures, they keep doing what they've been doing already. Copyright is big business and big business is copyright. Disney could absolutely start signing all of their media with NFT and every license holder would have X years to implement it properly. After that they can automate takedown notices for any commercial site/platform that uses their non-NFT'd images. Right now they need to manually verify if the Hulk coffee mug on Overstock.com is using licensed images or not.
- fooker 5y agoYour elaborate idea is defeated by screenshots.
- lottin 5y ago> If Getty signs an asset saying chime bought it at 'getty.com', that's proof enough. This is not proof enough. You don't know that getty 1) owns the asset 2) hasn't sold other "proofs of ownership" of the same asset to other people.
- tshaddox 5y agoBoth of those theoretical problems exist for physical paintings as well. You don't know that Salvator Mundi was actually painted by Leonardo da Vinci (maybe his gardener painted it and he lied to everyone saying it was him), or maybe he actually painted it several times. Perhaps one day we'll find evidence that the gardener actually painted it, or we'll find additional "original" copies, and suddenly the value of our current "original" will be reduced.
- lottin 5y agoWe were talking about ownership, not authorship. In the real world titles of ownership are issued by a trusted third party. They're not issued by the same party who claims ownership. But in the NFT world they are, and this means these titles of ownership can't be trusted. There's no way of assessing whether they're valid or not.
- Marsymars 5y agoThis doesn't really seem compatible with first-sale doctrine and how copyright around images works. If I want to buy licensed Hulk coffee mugs from any source, and resell them, Disney doesn't have any rights.
- root_axis 5y agoWhy not just sign the assets with a private key and verify its authenticity with the public key? What is the purpose of bolting a blockchain onto this idea?
- dumbfounder 5y agoNo. If you are able to attribute identity in some way to the address that created the NFT then you can reasonably assume the NFT is legitimate. There are ways to do this. One can publicly declare (and prove) they control the address through a 3rd party system (Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, or some decentralized method). You can also determine based off the activity of the address itself (what and when it created nfts in the past) and make certain assumptions about the validity of a self-proclaimed identity. The address becomes the identity in a way.
- manigandham 5y agoYou just repeated the same thing. That 3rd-party centralized system that's used for "identity" can just handle the ownership too. A decentralized NFT layer adds nothing when the ownership is still dependant on something else.
- tshaddox 5y agoBut ownership of anything is always dependent on something else. People can steal physical items from you. You can tell the police and maybe they'll return the item to you. But what if the police steal the item from you? These scenarios do not demonstrate that the notion of ownership is absurd.
- manigandham 5y agoYou're conflating vastly different things. You still own something even if you don't physically have it. The concept of ownership is granted by the by the laws we are governed by. Everything else is just recording those facts and transactions. That's why you can transfer ownership by writing it down on paper. NFTs are just fancy electronic documents. It's just paperwork.
- tshaddox 5y ago> NFTs are just fancy electronic documents. It's just paperwork. Yes, of course that's what NFTs are. Is someone claiming they are something else?
- tshaddox 5y ago> if we assume some other system takes care of documenting that the NFT was in fact created by the owner What other system are you talking about? I could determine that you control the NFT of a digital work by observing the artist's statement of issuance and your message demonstrating control of the NFT on the blockchain. Determining the validity of the artist's statement of issuance could be done using public-key cryptography. I fail to see what additional system is necessary.
- Drew_ 5y agoThe "additional system" would be your first qualifier for ownership > observing the artist's statement of issuance eg: having an authority affirm your ownership of something. The secondary system of using ownership of some piece of a blockchain is superfluous considering the first system is all you would need to prove ownership.
- dls2016 5y agoI've been saying this for a while: in the absence of reproduction rights or some other thing of value attached to them, NFTs are a fancy system of provenance.
- chime 5y agoPrecisely. When you license a digital asset, it has licensing terms associated with it - single entity use, multiple entity use, allowed form of media etc. Getty would sell me a new NFT for any asset I want to license and embed that signature in the asset I download. Even if current NFTs don't support everything, the blockchain algo could be extended incorporate the needs of the parties involved.
- kibwen 5y agoAnd how do you associate a given NFT as being issued by the true owner of a real-world asset? The answer: by trusting a centralized external authority to verify the association. And if you're already trusting that centralized authority, what's even the point of the NFT?
- tshaddox 5y agoCan you determine the authenticity of a physical painting, or would you trust experts?
- manigandham 5y agoThat's not related to this at all.
- lottin 5y agoOf course it's problematic. That's why most countries have land and vehicle registries managed by a trusted authority. If people had to rely on titles of ownership issued by random strangers it'd be chaos.
- manigandham 5y agoContracts only hold power because of the government which can adjudicate and enforce the laws. How those contracts are written, whether it's on paper or on the blockchain, is the least interesting part of it all. NFTs add no value that existing recordkeeping cant already do (usually much better and faster).
- TomSwirly 5y ago> I think it's pretty clear from the proposal that the only relevant NFT for some piece of digital media would be the NFT created by the original copyright holder of that piece of digital media. So in order for the NFT to work, you need some sort of way to identify the copyright holder before the NFT even exists. Don't see you the issue? If you can identify the copyright holder of a work without an NFT, what's the point of the NFT?