4 ms·
I disagree. Apple has a more diversified portfolio of business — they don’t need to go down the rabbit hole as deep as Google or Facebook to get value. Think o
by Spooky23 5y ago
I disagree. Apple has a more diversified portfolio of business — they don’t need to go down the rabbit hole as deep as Google or Facebook to get value.
Think of early Google… they made billions off of keyword advertising before they integrated things like mapping and created a surveillance network. I think a lot of that was driven by walled gardens like Facebook killing the open web.
My guess is that Apple could leverage their relationship with customers and trust in them to sell a premium ad product with coarser targeting or for certain categories. They could do ad placement in apps, for example, or combine ad placement with one click purchasing.
- coldpie 5y agoWhy does Apple need to get into ads at all? They seem plenty profitable already without abusing their users.
- nojito 5y agoBecause the current system/platforms of ads in existence is in anthesis to apples stance on privacy.
- vineyardmike 5y agoWhy replace ads when they could just kill them?
- Spooky23 5y agoThey’ve already increased the flagship phone cost like 250% Wall St demands earnings growth.
- npunt 5y agoI think you're right, it's hard to argue they'll do anything near the full extraction playbook that FB/Goog runs because of that diversification, and depending on where the ads are placed, it may not risk the brand much. My guess is app installs will be their target, for several reasons: 1. A lot of the most expensive/lucrative ads are for apps 2. Apple has better data on this - ad networks had to guess at what apps you had and how to attribute, while the iPhone knows with certainty. [1] 3. Apple already sells these ads in the App Store itself, so it stands to reason putting these ads in apps is just another step. 4. With IDFA gone, a lot of popular apps (that they want in the app store) are losing revenue and will be looking for alternate ways to support themselves. Better for the ecosystem that devs are compensated. Apple doesn't need to give ads the Apple treatment in the way they do hardware products; they can do the more 'good enough' TV & Music treatment of leveraging their position to get some low hanging fruit. It'll pay for itself pretty quickly and provide a nice revenue stream. The more strategic value this brings is it gets them a few steps closer to building their own search engine, providing a revenue carrot should they decide to (or need to) break with Google. Creating a search engine isn't exactly in Apple's wheelhouse, but they are shifting toward services and software more and more, it fits well with their privacy-oriented strategy, and Google does still leave a lot to be desired in UX and results. With Apple's very different incentive/revenue structure, there's many decisions they could make differently. [1] Android used to support grabbing the user's app list but that was shut off a few years back.
- paxys 5y agoIf they have an advertising network set up and realize they can extract more value out of it, will they choose not to just because they don't "need to"?
- ksec 5y agoIt is not about Apple selling Ads per se, it is about Apple trash talking tracking Ads while they are also selling tracking ads themselves. There is a different in tracking and mass data, cross site/ domain data gathering . Now it seems Apple has successfully lump these two together.
- Spooky23 5y agoWhat does any of this stuff mean? The obvious opportunity is to redefine what a “good ad” is!