9 ms·
So, question: Is any kind of disapproval of Israel's policies on palestinians now by definition antisemitic or is there a way to voice legitimate criticism? I
by xg15 5y ago
So, question: Is any kind of disapproval of Israel's policies on palestinians now by definition antisemitic or is there a way to voice legitimate criticism?
I agree, the "If I were a jew" sentence is an extremely tasteless and and insensitive way to put it, but from the rest of the quotes, his intent to criticize Israel's policies, not call into question the right to exist seems pretty clear.
If someone criticized the Chinese government, you wouldn't automatically accuse them of anti-asian racism either, would you?
- MaxLeiter 5y agoThe reason so many criticisms are judged as anti-Semitic is because they are anti-Semitic. Often, they will have reasonable criticisms and then delegitimize their argument by stereotyping, supporting conspiracy theories, or conflating Judaism and Zionism. In this case, I think its most specifically: “If I were a Jew I would be concerned about my insatiable appetite for war and killing in defense of myself.” Being Jewish doesn’t mean being a Zionist, pro-Israel, or bloodthirsty