3 ms·
I've met Jews. I didn't get the impression that they have an "insatiable appetite for war and killing". Would you say the Jews I met have an "insatiable appet
by duxup 5y ago
I've met Jews.
I didn't get the impression that they have an "insatiable appetite for war and killing".
Would you say the Jews I met have an "insatiable appetite for war and killing"?
- nojokes 5y agoI have met Jews (Israelis to be more precise), Russians and Americans. All have been very nice people. But I think it could be said about all of them as nations to have to some degree "insatiable appetite for war and killing" considering their recent history. Naturally the Russians would label me a russophobe for saying that. Not sure what Americans would label me. I also understand the position Israelis are in and I understand their actions. But they have made a critical mistake from the beginning and what they continue to make - not giving a fair compensation to the people they displace. I think most problems would not exists today if that had been followed from the beginning. Perhaps I am mistaken, so please enlighten me. I also envy Israelis that they can be in such position.
- whimsicalism 5y agoPeople != nations. Conflating the two is bad because you start blaming people for the sins of their nation and that is how you get to dehumanization.
- pxc 5y agoAlso it's in the interest of the Zionist state to identify 'Israel' with 'Jews' If you're opposed to Zionism or the state of Israel, you shouldn't grant them that identification. If you assume or assert that all Jews support Israel's settler-colonial project, you're also playing into the state of Israel's rhetorical strategies that conflate the survival and military supremacy of the Zionist state with Jewish safety, opposition of Zionism with hatred toward Jews, etc. Failing to distinguish between the people group and the nation-state that claims to represent or serve them is not only rude or dehumanizing or sloppy in this case, but counterproductive for anti-Zionism as a cause. Anti-imperialism is not served by racism.
- nojokes 5y agoI completely agree. Nations are aggregate of people and in addition are not always in full control of the state that represents them. But would US have started latest wars without popular support of Americans? To some degree everyone is guilty. Regardless I agree based on the comments about the culprit other options that his opinions add racist overtone and perhaps his words should be evaluated in the larger context.
- grumple 5y agoCan you name a nation that doesn't have an appetite for war and killing?
- nojokes 5y agoHistorically most (if not all?) of the nations had to have some appetite for war and killing - otherwise they would not have become nations.
- grumple 5y agoSo why did you call out Israel, the US, and Russia and not the others? I'm not trying to start a flame war here, I'm just curious as to what makes them special. There are many other nations involved in larger-scale conflicts right now. There are many others that have been involved in more conflicts globally historically. Many that have and do oppress and murder on a regular basis. I will say the US and Russia do get involved too much in outside conflicts, but Israel's ongoing conflict is paralleled in many other nations right now.
- nojokes 5y agoBecause I said historically and some nations have been forced to counter invasion or other form of repression to become an independent nation. I actually did not call out any country. I just included US and Russia as examples of more known countries that have started recent more known military conflicts. My motivation was to point out that "insatiable appetite for war and killing" is by itself nothing more than a political statement.
- ant6n 5y agoI’ve met Jews. I’ve learned to avoid discussing the Israel/Palestine conflict, because often the discussions turn very awkward quickly, and previously reasonable people who appear to have humanist views suddenly don’t sound so reasonable anymore. It’s a complicated subject especially for people connected to the issues. There are a lot of dark feelings all around the issue, that could get a lot of people fired if they talked about them openly.