3 ms·
The people change defense obviously doesn't work for Damore, who was fired over his actions while employed at Google Lots of weird comments in this thread.
by whimsicalism 5y ago
The people change defense obviously doesn't work for Damore, who was fired over his actions while employed at Google
Lots of weird comments in this thread.
- cloverich 5y agomoreover he immediately posted a “fired for telling the truth “ response - perhaps he’s since changed but very different circumstance.
- ehsankia 5y agoYeah, I don't have a very strong opinion on Damore, but the two situations are clearly not the same. One was published 14 years ago and another was published in the same week where it blew up.
- thu2111 5y agoThey're clearly not the same because Damore said nothing anywhere near as offensive as this. He said, paraphrased, that there are fewer women in tech than men because they are less interested in it. He backed it up with a whole pile of research showing that this obviously true claim is true. And he pointed out that women are biologically different to men, so maybe that is part of the explanation, and even if it is, there's nothing wrong with not wanting to be a programmer (which is in a sense a tautology, it's a way of saying "women are different because they're women"). In particular he bent over backwards to carefully spell out that he was not claiming women are worse at programming than men, perhaps because he knew the dangerous liars he was picking a fight with would also lie about his words - which they did, immediately, across the entire media and with vigor. Damore also tried to keep these views inside the company. Now this guy made very explicitly offensive comments broadcast to the whole world on his blog, which claims that all Jewish people are the same, that by implication they are morally inferior to people whose hearts are not filled with war, and that they should feel guilt and shame about this. No comparison, indeed.
- namelessoracle 5y agoOne is a member of a privileged group and one is not. One of those groups can do or say whatever they want and be insulated from the consequences. Thats how you know they are NOT the privileges group. Newspeak is real and in effect btw.
- eli_gottlieb 5y ago>One was published 14 years ago Right, so in one case, the company clearly ought to have known he was an antisemite before hiring him as Chief of Diversity. In the other, the company was hiring for a technical role and didn't bother asking about his political or social views.
- jonfw 5y agoDamore never backed down
- mellosouls 5y agoGiven his original point was that voices countering the radical left wouldn't be tolerated, and they proved him right, it's not obvious what he could back down from?