4 ms·
People will figure it out. For most normal kids, they just adapt. The problem is when kids have a problem that parents can't handle or don't understand. People
by Spooky23 5y ago
People will figure it out.
For most normal kids, they just adapt. The problem is when kids have a problem that parents can't handle or don't understand. People miss this, because they (rightfully) have a tight emotional attachment to their children.
My kids go to a private school, and I'm a volunteer parent/peer advisor to help parents with various issues. One of the hardest conversations to have is when a child is struggling, and the right answer is for that child to be in public school where resources exist -- the financial model doesn't support having the support staff and specialist teachers. People feel strongly about small class sizes and other benefits of the private school, but that matters less if the child needs services.
That's fundamentally an issue with homeschooling. There's nobody to say "hey, we have a problem here" when Sally can't read, or Johnny doesn't understand geometry because Khan academy isn't working and mom can't explain it.
- ksdale 5y agoI mean, there's an absolutely ridiculous number of kids who can't do things to grade level in public schools, and grade level requirements aren't particularly ambitious for what a kid could learn, given their age.
- Matticus_Rex 5y ago"That's fundamentally an issue with homeschooling. There's nobody to say "hey, we have a problem here" when Sally can't read, or Johnny doesn't understand geometry because Khan academy isn't working and mom can't explain it." Three things: 1. There are lots of private options for this, at least in any major metro. 2. From my experience with homeschoolers, the sheer amount of parent attention they tend to get lends itself towards figuring these things out (especially with help from a homeschooling community or the aforementioned private options). 3. From my experience as a public school teacher, most of the kids who needed services didn't get them, and I saw very few situations where the services seemed to make a significant difference (though there were some). I've seen more success stories around learning disabilities from homeschoolers than I have from kids at public schools (and in fact often the learning disability was a key impetus for the switch to homeschool). So the question is, "compared to what?" Kids with strong parent advocates are likely to get what they need in whatever environment they're in. Kids without them aren't likely to, but there's selection bias against that in homeschool. Yes, one can have a great result with public school, and sometimes that's the right call for a family, but after my stint in the public schools I'm much more confident in a well-meaning parent figuring out the solution with a kid they spend lots of time with than I am in that same parent spending much less time with the kid and rolling the dice with public school specialists and support services.
- Spooky23 5y ago> From my experience with homeschoolers, the sheer amount of parent attention they tend to get lends itself towards figuring these things out It depends. Some parents focus homeschooling on religion. Or skip schooling so their 11 year old can focus on his baseball career and 3 travel teams. Or have no clue.
- Matticus_Rex 5y agoI've seen public school parents spend their time with their kids on making sure their kids don't believe anything that could challenge their religious or political beliefs, and many public school parents who encourage their kids to focus on sports alone to the exclusion of anything and everything else. Again -- compared to what? I was homeschooled K-7 and again in 12th. I know lots of homeschool kids whose parents insulated them from the world (including mine, though less so than many) due to religion or just eccentricity. Almost all of us are successful, however, and very few stayed locked in that bubble. A key piece of that is because we became self-directed learners.
- lemming 5y agoMy wife and I are homeschooling our daughter. She's still pretty little, 7 1/2. She went to school for a year and then we started homeschooling, not because anything was particularly wrong at school but we just love spending time with her (and she with us) and our lives are flexible enough to do it. In her first year at school, the teacher was incredibly effusive about her. We were interested in maths because before she went to school we had always thought that she struggled with anything to do with numbers, but the teacher reassured us that everything was fine. But within a week of us sitting down with her to do maths, it became very clear that she had absolutely no idea of even the most basic concepts around numbers, sequences, addition, or anything else. We asked her how she had managed to do the material that the teacher had shown us, and she looked a little sheepish and said: "well, we do all that in groups..." I don't know how long she could have kept faking it in the school system. But at least in our case, our daughter was perfectly capable of playing the system and slipping through the cracks, in a way that was completely impossible with us one on one. We're lucky that we're educated and have resources etc, but our daughter will absolutely be better off getting the help that we can organise for her and the personalisation in her learning that we can offer than she would be in the school system.