9 ms·
>> We let the kids learn on their own the things they wanted to learn when they wanted to learn them. This was wonderful. I'm sure that it was. But good luck
by sandworm101 5y ago
>> We let the kids learn on their own the things they wanted to learn when they wanted to learn them. This was wonderful.
I'm sure that it was. But good luck to them when they need to learn something important that isn't fun. There are times in every profession when you have to grind your way through something horrible. Want to be a lawyer? You will have to understand the rules of evidence regardless of what type of lawyer you want to be. Want to be a doctor? There will be anatomy that you will hate memorizing. There is something to be said for forcing kids to learn things they hate. It is necessary preparation for the important stuff that comes later, stuff they cannot learn from their parents. That's what advanced education is, learning something because an expert tells you to. Whether you enjoy every moment of it or not is beside the point. You can judge things once you become an expert.
I have to go away for a two-week training course on monday. It is going to be hell. Twelve days of memorizing stupid powerpoints about stuff I will probably never use. There will be tests at the end. I will pass them. My training at school/university, learning stuff I often hated, allows me to power through such things. I can sit in that chair hour after hour without drifting. Not everyone can do that. They work very different jobs. Their employer doesn't spend tens of thousands of dollars sending them to such courses.
- true_religion 5y agoSure then maybe this won’t produce doctors or lawyers, but there are plenty of professions where mere intellect can suffice. Ivy League schools for example are really good at producing the kind of people who can pass McKinseys first year deathmarch, but most of us don’t work there and don’t want deathmarches in general.
- sandworm101 5y ago>> then maybe this won’t produce doctors or lawyers Isn't that a decision that the children should be allowed to make for themselves once they are adults? School should give them sufficient resources for them to attack any profession, from soldier to priest, pilot to surgeon. Asking a child to make such choices, allowing them to forgo certain subjects, harms them in the long term. It limits their potential options. A few years ago I read that "social media influencer" was a more desired trade amongst highschool kids than doctor/lawyer/fighter pilot. Such kids should not be allowed to make educational decisions.
- dsr_ 5y agoRight now, "social media influencer" is a more realistic immediate job than doctor, lawyer, or fighter pilot. To be a doctor, you need a 4 year college degree, then acceptance into a medical school, then pass the medical school courses and do N years of residency. The average medical school graduate has $200K of debt at that point. To be a lawyer, you need blah blah blah law school, and then it turns out the USA has too many lawyers already... so the average entry-level lawyer makes $48K. Yes, really. To be a social media influencer, you need about $2000 in startup costs and a lot of luck, as well as some degree of actual work. There are roughly a million people with 100,000+ followers on Instagram or YouTube or TikTok. Interestingly, there are about a million lawyers and about a million doctors in the USA. Finally, there are about 15,000 pilots in the US armed forces, but only about 2200 attack or fighter role aircraft. In total: a kid with no particular educational affinity is making a reasonable immediate choice to pursue "social media influencer" over doctor/lawyer/fighter pilot. It's probably a terrible long-term career choice, but so is fighter pilot.
- busterarm 5y ago> To be a doctor, you need a 4 year college degree, then acceptance into a medical school, then pass the medical school courses and do N years of residency. The average medical school graduate has $200K of debt at that point. It's not even that simple anymore. There's also the PGY1 year. There aren't nearly enough residencies to satisfy demand anymore. You might have to change specialties a few times before you land a residency. We're at the point where if you didn't go to medical school in the US, you're SOL. Even if you did, it's a struggle -- hope you went to a great medical school. This at a time when we have higher demand for doctors than ever. Nobody wants to change the residency situation because the economics of it don't work out.
- lostcolony 5y agoI don't disagree, but I think you're overlooking one thing. There are more kids wanting to be social media influencers than there are doctors, lawyers, or fighter pilots. The chances aren't purely based on how much demand there is for a given job, but also on how much supply. For that one million spots competition is fiercer.
- citizenpaul 5y ago>McKinseys first year deathmarch You write that like everyone automatically has any idea what it is.
- Inhibit 5y agoIt'd be nice if someone expanded on the subject. I assume it's this McKinsey: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/McKinsey_%26_Company https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/McKinsey_%26_Company And infer they treat the new hires harshly?
- derivagral 5y agoI don't work at the top consulting firms (of which McKinsey is one) but the first year or 2 at any major financial or consulting institution is a bit of a meme as to what they go through in hopes of making it. The 80+ hour weeks working on pitch decks, next-morning deadlines, etc, aren't just a Hollywood meme. I've read some of the 600+ slide powerpoint decks that exist in consulting and finance, and I think I got interesting information out of the experience exactly once (Radio ads were a close #2 in advertising ROI against the internet back in mid 2010s, with TV and other mediums far behind.) There's a few blogs around about it; this one seems less hyperbolic than your average news headline but does mention the hours: https://managementconsulted.com/interview-first-year-mckinsey/ https://managementconsulted.com/interview-first-year-mckinse...
- leetcrew 5y agoyes, a certain amount of discipline is required to get through boring, yet important, stuff in life. I'm really not sure US grade school does a great job instilling that virtue though. the material is generally a complete joke for any student of above-average intelligence. I'm no genius, but I did all my homework during the class before it was due and rarely studied for tests. I was in for a rude awakening when I got to college, which is a pretty common story.
- clipradiowallet 5y agoI "learned to learn" during training in the military FWIW. The school system helped me with that skill, but it really took off in basic training and further in job-specific-training. A big part of that is the motivation during training...that if you fail, there are serious consequences, and you'll be stuck digging latrines until your term is complete.
- TheAdamAndChe 5y agoAny ideas on how to instill that do-or-die mentality in people who haven't gone to the military?
- sandworm101 5y agoAnything in the outdoors. Rock climbing. Either you learn these knots or you will die. Either you learn how to navigate, find the trail to the cabin, or you are going to spend the night in the rain. Either you remember to bring your gloves ore you are going to loose fingers. Either you learn to read and understand avalanche warnings or ... everything in the outdoors comes with a risk that focuses the mind.
- adolph 5y ago> There is something to be said for forcing kids to learn things they hate. There is also something to said for developing a kid’s sensitivity to and ownership of their individual intrinsic motivation. If using extrinsic motivation works for your kids, that’s great for you. Deciding on an approach for the child one rears out of concern for a lack of lawyers and doctors doesn’t sound like a sound decision process.
- tomp 5y agoYou’re comparing apples to oranges. There’s a big difference between wanting to learn and having to learn. Someone wants to be a doctor? Great, soon they’ll realise that they need to learn anatomy, and they’ll do that if they’re sufficiently motivated! But most of school was, you have to learn something because an adult (and not very smart adult either ... most teachers aren’t experts, they just seem like that, to kids) said so. I don’t care why Hamlet said something, I never did, I never will, I never needed that knowledge and never will, and to the extent that you can maybe learn some general life principles from such books, there are many other, better ways of learning that, including many better and more interesting books. Even the employment course you’re taking, you want to take - you’re getting something out of it (a promotion, hopefully) - even though even in your reply there’s some amount of bitterness about having to learn it (“memorizing stupid powerpoints about stuff I will probably never use”) - now imagine being a child with much less independence and agency and multiply that feeling of dread by 1000x...
- sandworm101 5y agoLearning Shakespeare has nothing to do with Shakespeare. It is taught is because doing so forces students to understand language. To read Shakespeare they must learn to examine language for nuance. By doing so they become better speakers regardless of whether they ever revisit the material.
- lostcolony 5y agoBut why Shakespeare, especially given that the consensus amongst schoolkids is that it's indecipherable (given the language difference to today)? Shakespeare is taught...because Shakespeare has always been taught. It's recognized as important; to be fair, it is from an objective sense, but subjectively there is no reason to read it, nor even to watch it performed unless someone wants to. You learn language by practicing language. You can read or watch anything and better understand the nuances of a language; even better to talk to people who speak it. English evolves because of the latter; Shakespeare doesn't. Everyone who speaks a language other than English learned to do so without Shakespeare. I am unconvinced of the necessity of reading/watching Shakespeare unless someone wants to; it is but one means to an end.
- baryphonic 5y agoI'm not sure this is a fair characterization of GP. He wrote that his wife poured lots of energy into schooling the kids, but also that they learned things on their own when they wanted to learn them. Certainly we should assume that the energy poured into their schooling involved discipline for the kids involved. I didn't get the impression that the kids were frolicking through the Austrian Alps behind Maria von Trapp as their teacher. > There is something to be said for forcing kids to learn things they hate. It is necessary preparation for the important stuff that comes later, stuff they cannot learn from their parents. That's what advanced education is, learning something because an expert tells you to. Whether you enjoy every moment of it or not is beside the point. You can judge things once you become an expert. I'm not sure what to make of this. How is "forcing" kids to learn things they hate "necessary" preparation for what comes later? Is it the only way to instill discipline? I'd rather force my kids to do the productive, boring things like chores (washing and folding laundry, cleaning dishes, cleaning their room, cleaning their bathroom and playroom, taking care of the pets) which will instill the same discipline and delayed gratification without potentially making them hate learning and schooling at a young age when they are least emotionally prepared to handle it. Plus, if they're being challenged in school they'll have that experience of leaping into the unknown, which can be quite scary and requires discipline. I find it much more likely that homeschooling induces that challenge and discipline over public schools, where above-average kids are often bored and subject to authoritarian threats. > I have to go away for a two-week training course on monday. It is going to be hell. Twelve days of memorizing stupid powerpoints about stuff I will probably never use. There will be tests at the end. I will pass them. My training at school/university, learning stuff I often hated, allows me to power through such things. I can sit in that chair hour after hour without drifting. Not everyone can do that. They work very different jobs. Their employer doesn't spend tens of thousands of dollars sending them to such courses. I'm not sure why romanticizing or glorifying suffering and waste is somehow the raison d'être for public schooling. I've worked in toxic environments before where some of the employees, fully resigned to how toxic the place is, would make statements like, "not a lot of people could succeed in this environment." I got the hell out of each of those situations as soon as I could. In my opinion, I'd rather suffer for people like my kids or my wife or God or even to defend my community for which I am duty bound, but not for my employer. Best of luck with that horrible upcoming training course.
- dcolkitt 5y agoThis post has a fatal misconception that school teaches people to "learn how to learn". In your specific argument, it's the belief that forcing kids to master boring material will augment their ability to learn boring material in adulthood. Cognitive psychology has consistently refuted this theory again and again. Transfer of learning is virtually non-existent.[1] When a student learns a topic he learns the very specific skills related to that topic. There's no spillover or improvement to the ability to learn other, even closely related, topics. [1]https://www.econlib.org/archives/2012/08/low_transfer_of.html https://www.econlib.org/archives/2012/08/low_transfer_of.htm...
- yonaguska 5y agoAnecdotally, I learned Japanese. At a later date, I studied Hungarian in a cram school. Two of us learned Hungarian much faster than our classmates- we both had studied Japanese. Most of the students had also studied other languages. Something about learning languages that were so grammatically different from English seemed to help with building mental models and stop "translating" things back and forth from English- which made the language much easier to pick up. Developing learning techniques does help in learning other things. Learning boring things however, I think that's always going to be hard for me.
- ed25519FUUU 5y agoI have a feeling this anecdote has more to do with the personality of people who have the drive, desire, and passion to self-study Japanese.
- OJFord 5y agoI disagree, a lot of learning a language is transferable, but not because it's 'learning how to learn', just because it's the same. Grammars are largely described using the same system, with different languages using different parts of it (and more or less - Latin quite a lot; English quite little). Learning a second language (that's different enough) exposes you to more of the available grammatical constructs, so when you learn a third there's less that could possibly be new, and probably quite a bit of grammatical overlap with your first or second language.
- Spooky23 5y agoPeople will figure it out. For most normal kids, they just adapt. The problem is when kids have a problem that parents can't handle or don't understand. People miss this, because they (rightfully) have a tight emotional attachment to their children. My kids go to a private school, and I'm a volunteer parent/peer advisor to help parents with various issues. One of the hardest conversations to have is when a child is struggling, and the right answer is for that child to be in public school where resources exist -- the financial model doesn't support having the support staff and specialist teachers. People feel strongly about small class sizes and other benefits of the private school, but that matters less if the child needs services. That's fundamentally an issue with homeschooling. There's nobody to say "hey, we have a problem here" when Sally can't read, or Johnny doesn't understand geometry because Khan academy isn't working and mom can't explain it.
- ksdale 5y agoI mean, there's an absolutely ridiculous number of kids who can't do things to grade level in public schools, and grade level requirements aren't particularly ambitious for what a kid could learn, given their age.
- Matticus_Rex 5y ago"That's fundamentally an issue with homeschooling. There's nobody to say "hey, we have a problem here" when Sally can't read, or Johnny doesn't understand geometry because Khan academy isn't working and mom can't explain it." Three things: 1. There are lots of private options for this, at least in any major metro. 2. From my experience with homeschoolers, the sheer amount of parent attention they tend to get lends itself towards figuring these things out (especially with help from a homeschooling community or the aforementioned private options). 3. From my experience as a public school teacher, most of the kids who needed services didn't get them, and I saw very few situations where the services seemed to make a significant difference (though there were some). I've seen more success stories around learning disabilities from homeschoolers than I have from kids at public schools (and in fact often the learning disability was a key impetus for the switch to homeschool). So the question is, "compared to what?" Kids with strong parent advocates are likely to get what they need in whatever environment they're in. Kids without them aren't likely to, but there's selection bias against that in homeschool. Yes, one can have a great result with public school, and sometimes that's the right call for a family, but after my stint in the public schools I'm much more confident in a well-meaning parent figuring out the solution with a kid they spend lots of time with than I am in that same parent spending much less time with the kid and rolling the dice with public school specialists and support services.
- sildur 5y ago> I'm sure that it was. But good luck to them when they need to learn something important that isn't fun. At the end of the comment he says his sons are well rounded adults. > I have to go away for a two-week training course on monday. It is going to be hell. Twelve days of memorizing stupid powerpoints about stuff I will probably never use. No offense, but that sounds pretty miserable. I'm on my forties, with two kids, and never had to subject myself to such things. Life is too short for that.
- Duralias 5y ago> At the end of the comment he says his sons are well rounded adults. While they are likely doing fine, parents usually aren't the correct people to ask, the kids could be withholding how much they've been struggling and even if they aren't no parent would objectively say if their kids didn't turn out into "well rounded adults", unless the parent truly hated their kids. Parents like making their kids look better than they are.
- sildur 5y agoHah, you had a nice catch-22 in there: either I, as a parent, am oblivious to my kid's shortcomings, or I "truly hate them". Well, that's not how it works in real life.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- theodric 5y agoI had an extremelysimilar upbringing, and I'm in senior tech management in a systemically-relevant bank now and will be retiring at 40 (in 1.5 years). I didn't need anyone's luck to learn and succeed. I had an end-goal, and I did what was necessary to get there. Drive is the decider, not compliance.
- splithalf 5y ago“That's what advanced education is, learning something because an expert tells you to.” Many share this conception but it’s not a very useful model I would argue.
- voisin 5y ago> You will have to understand the rules of evidence regardless of what type of lawyer you want to be. This is the problem. We force everyone through a meat grinder with this paternalistic bullshit about being well-rounded. If and when it becomes necessary to know something, you learn it with more motivation and so it becomes easier to learn and remember. We need to stop force feeding people things that aren’t directly relevant or that they have no interest in. Source: am also a lawyer and would say easily 1/2 of what is taught in law school was never used again and promptly forgotten after the exam. I am certain the same apples to doctors, architects, etc etc etc.