3 ms·
The US already spends more on education per student than any country in the world except for Luxembourg, Austria and Norway. In postsecondary education, only Lu
by whatshisface 5y ago
The US already spends more on education per student than any country in the world except for Luxembourg, Austria and Norway. In postsecondary education, only Luxembourg spends more. If money (at the whole-system funding level) was the problem the problem would already be solved.
https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd
- capableweb 5y agoIf the US is inefficient that people are still very far behind when it comes to average education compared to the rest of the world that spends less per student, you either need to spend a lot more or make sure it's effectively spent. The argument that the US already spends a lot so nothing should be done feels loose at best.
- sandworm101 5y ago>> If the US is inefficient that people are still very far behind The US education system is not there to accelerate students, to lift them up. It is model the population to suit the needs of the country. That's why nearly every aspect of a child's life revolves around school, from how and when they eat to who they socialize with. The system is there to reinforce national ideas. Some of that is noble ("try hard and get ahead") and some of it is not ("money counts"). When viewed from that perspective it works very well: little ever seems to change from one generation to the next. Freedom through social stability.
- project2501b 5y agoYet, some of the neighbourhoods and districts are so grossly underfunded, teachers have to put money out of their pocket for school supplies... hmmmm
- mbg721 5y agoIf your plumbing is leaking so badly that you can't get anything out of the upstairs faucet, you don't just crank up the water pressure.
- NoGravitas 5y agoI think the problem with that analysis of the problem is that education spending in the US is highly unequal. Some school districts spend much more than necessary, while some don't have the funding to afford textbooks or safe school buildings. The main cause of this is that schools are funded by local property taxes, which depend on local house values and local incomes. Poor areas can't afford good schools, which makes it harder for kids raised in those areas to escape from poverty. Consider the Corridor of Shame: http://projects.aljazeera.com/2014/south-carolina-schools/ http://projects.aljazeera.com/2014/south-carolina-schools/ It may well be the case that US aggregate education spending is plenty high – but unless it were centrally collected and equitably distributed (taking into account differences in cost of living, cost of real-estate, etc.) to produce equivalent average outcomes, that's not really relevant.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThey've tried this with under-performing schools (typically in urban areas). Throwing money at a problem doesn't make it magically go away. What works is breaking up the school and divvying up the students/teachers among schools that aren't under-performing.
- dwater 5y agoAKA dispersing concentrated poverty so that no one part of the system is overwhelmed.
- leetcrew 5y agothis isn't really true. the difference in funding from property tax is smoothed out (or more!) at the state level in most US states. some of the poorest school districts (eg, baltimore) have the highest funding per student. they still produce abysmal outcomes.
- jessedhillon 5y agoAt least in CA, and probably other liberal states, you have what is ironically called the Local Control Funding Formula (LCFF) that distributes funding equally, more or less, and tries to erase these advantages. https://www.cde.ca.gov/fg/aa/lc/ https://www.cde.ca.gov/fg/aa/lc/
- greesil 5y agoFrom your source: "The total government and private expenditures on education" It's not just public school. And the data includes preschool, which is notoriously expensive.
- bena 5y agoThe US also spends more on defense than the next 10 nations... combined. But we never talk about cutting the defense budget.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 5y agoLikely, it’s money at the parental level that is what is lacking most now, and the body of supporting research has become deafening. From benefits cliffs, to the broken poverty measure, to ballooning costs of housing, healthcare and college, to stagnant wages it’s getting harder and harder for a hard working family to maintain an existence above that of outright poverty. >When critics insist that American teachers need to be held accountable for the poor performance of American school children, the teachers shoot back that they are being held accountable for the failure of American parents and taxpayers to take care of their children. >When some of us point out that there has been no improvement in the performance of all high school students or of protected subgroups of students in the United States on NAEP measures of reading and mathematics in 30 years, they tell us we should consider ourselves lucky that we have teachers who have been able to hold student performance steady while the American people have been sending them students who get poorer and more isolated every year. >…the U.S. spends much more per student on our schools than the countries with the best education performance. But it is also the case that other countries, with higher student performance and lower school spending per student, have smaller disparities in income between their wealthiest families and their poorest ones, and despite that, spend much more than we do on the support of families with young children on everything from child allowances to child care and early childhood education. From my vantage point, our budgets for children, families and schools, if you take everything into account, do very little about the enormous problems caused by concentrated poverty and racial segregation and then load all the problems that causes onto the schools. >…It is a whole lot cheaper to do right by our children starting when mom is pregnant than it is to wait six years, when it is a whole lot harder to do what must be done to give these kids a chance in a world in which the skill threshold for earning a decent living is getting higher and higher. -Marc Tucker https://ncee.org/2019/12/child-poverty-and-its-impact-on-education-in-the-u-s/ https://ncee.org/2019/12/child-poverty-and-its-impact-on-edu...