11 ms·
Ask HN: What is the most bloated website you use
Looking for examples of bloated websites where you are seeking some textual data/information but have to suffer to retrieve it. EDIT: Preferably sites that do not require log in to access the data/information.
- sydthrowaway 5y agoAll3dp.com. It’s a scourge.
- XCSme 5y agoFacebook, not only it is bloated but many times it simply fails to work (chat not working, pages not loading, etc.).
- n4s33r 5y agoSharePoint
- arkitaip 5y agoReddit has lots of valuable info, especially if you are looking for tips on products, but the UI isn't just bloated, it's downright hostile with its dark patterns to make you use their terrible mobile app.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoOld reddit is much better all around in that regard.
- trextrex 5y agoThe old Reddit UI is still available under the old.reddit.com domain. I use browser extensions to automatically redirect to the old saner UI every time I visit Reddit.
- hobos_delight 5y agoThere's no need for a browser extension, you can enable it as a setting in your profile if you're logged in.
- djhworld 5y agoThe 'new' Reddit UI caused my Intel macbook to get really hot just clicking around, it's not so bad on the M1 but I still prefer the old reddit UI, which feels snappy.
- tlb 5y agoMy bank (a Bank of America subsidiary). Takes about 12 seconds to log in, 5 - 6 seconds to load each page in their site. My typical session (check that a transaction went through, or read a message through their secure portal) takes a minute or two. Infuriating. Data transfer isn't a major factor, it's all delay in their servers.
- dole 5y agoour regional electric utility provider's site is slick, all ajax and pretty and every click takes at least 30 seconds to complete an action. it's noticably slower than most other bloated sites, and i don't understand how their developers, much less anyone else can stand it. it can't be THAT much faster being local to the machine or network.
- frou_dh 5y agoI don't actually use it that often, but when I do use Jira, every action seems to have a noticeable delay. I don't remember it being like that a decade ago. Maybe there was a big rewrite or two that bloated things up?
- cies 5y agoJira, hands down. So slow! It's at a point we're looking for alternatives.
- boboche 5y ago+10 amen to that. In 13 years it went from something I pushed and installed at every client I helped with business processes, help desk, Dev… to an overbloated frustrating mess to operate and manage. Just changing a dropdown field’s content now is hidden in sublayers that requires a bookmark if you are not toying with that on a daily basis. (not everybody is an actual full time Jira admin, and a Jira admin should’nt have the mental load of an Exchange admin for such an application). Happy to hear about alternatives experiences as well.
- cosmodisk 5y ago"not everybody is an actual full time Jira admin, and a Jira admin should’nt have the mental load of an Exchange admin for such an application". Couldn't agree more. I've got admin rights to quite a few systems, including Exchange, which is a pretty big ship,so to speak. However, having tried Jira it's hands down the most convoluted piece of software I've ever seen. It took me less time to spin up an instance on AWS+ configure its access to the internet than it took to make a few changes on Jira. God knows how they managed to do It.
- jkingsbery 5y agoEvery team I was a part of between 2007 and 2014 used Jira, and I pretty much haven't used it since. It was notoriously slow back then.
- hughrr 5y ago
- thrower123 5y agoThe Wells Fargo website is just broken most of the time. I'll click on my account, when it does let me log in, and it automatically logs me out.
- blinktag 5y agoThere are too many to list nowadays. I keep one browser setup with JavaScript disabled for when I want to look up a product review, a recipe, or a how-to (even on my mobile devices). I’ve set all my browsers to disable autoplay (why is this not the default?). The web is becoming a miserable, slow, annoying experience. It’s hard to believe that as we have the best tools ever and the fastest computers that we’re choosing to inflict the most burdensome and repellent experiences on our users. God help us.
- jbverschoor 5y agoAh.. so you need a gatekeeper for the quality of the deployed software....
- travisjungroth 5y agoWalled garden seems popular based on behavior, but rarely a position that a user reasons themselves into. People who really care about this stuff would rather use emacs as a browser than an app store. Not trying to make a judgement, but it really seems like a vocal minority / silent majority case.
- coldpie 5y agoNoScript and uBlock Origin go a long way to making the web usable-ish. There's still hurdles, but at least you have to opt into those hurdles instead of having every website punch you in the face with garbage. Works on Firefox for Android, too. The thing that's driving all of the bad behavior you're talking about is the advertising business model. The sooner we can destroy web advertising as a viable business model, the better.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoNoscript is such a PITA though. A phenomenal app, but goes to show it's borderline impossible to stop that abuse as it makes your experience almost entirely unusable.
- 5y ago
- smt88 5y agoEvery news or recipe site is basically a disaster now. I don't understand how anyone can browse without uBlock Origin installed on their phone. The dual motivations of SEO and making money from ads have just saturated those sites.
- sofixa 5y agoNot every both the Guardian and BBC ( who also have a recipe site) are pretty OK.
- Jtsummers 5y agoCurrent recipe sites: <ad> Make Cookies Like Grandma Used To! <ad> [Jump to recipe] <- only works half the time Let me tell you about my time with my grandmother, making cookies with her on Sunday afternoons in the summer. <ad> [READ MORE] So there I was, making a mess like usual. <ad> <20 more sentence or paragraph and ad pairings> Recipe: [READ MORE] Ingredients: - 2 1/2 cups of flour - 1/2 cup of sugar - Eggs (wait, how many?) ... 1. Beat sugar and butter in a mixer. [READ MORE]
- betamaxthetape 5y agoThe Twitter website on mobile devices. I've just timed myself to see how long it took to view my own twitter profile on my phone (I don't use Twitter on my phone, hence I'm not logged in). It took 15 seconds to load the profile, but I couldn't view any tweets until I'd pressed the "Not Now" button to the pop-up asking me to install the app. Five seconds later, I was able to view my most recent / pinned tweet. This is all for a service that delivers a timeline of (primarily) text, with some images and video. It should not take 20 seconds to load!
- FabHK 5y agoAnd Twitter refuses to work without Javascript. For 280 characters of text...
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoThat is only true when using a web browser or some other software you cannot easily control. I wrote a script to read Twitter without Javascript, without a web browser. Text-only, as it should be (280 chars of text) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27056734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27056734
- nojser 5y agoOriginally it was just a fullscreen nag div on top of the already rendered content, so if you can delete elements, it should work for viewing or you can use something like Nitter.net Nitter.net[0] solves a lot of these problems and paired with Redirector[1], it's a transparent switch out. There's an expired cert issue 3 days ago, but there are other instances[2] https://github.com/zedeus/nitter https://github.com/zedeus/nitter https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/redirector/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/redirector/ https://github.com/zedeus/nitter/wiki/Instances https://github.com/zedeus/nitter/wiki/Instances
- dalmo3 5y agoI only visit twitter through links shared by friends, and ever since their last redesign 50-80% of the links give an "error loading" message which may or may not go away after reloading the page a few times. When/if the tweet finally loads, it shows totally unrelated messages at the bottom. I still have to click on it and load it again if I want to see the comments thread. The upside is that the redesign was the most effective way to keep me completely off twitter.
- iamben 5y agobrooklynvegan.com - on my relatively well specced (intel) Mac it'll start up the fan and grind to a halt at some point.
- fuzzy2 5y agoI think Yammer takes first place. It's required reading at work (the main feed). It loads incredibly slowly (I think it's like 5 redirects for auth and whatnot) and the default "What's new" view is entirely useless. Jira and Confluence are excruciatingly slow, too, but at least the information isn't hidden behind useless feeds.
- igetspam 5y agoOuch. Someone tried to force yammer on us at a previous company because of a Good Ole Boys Club relationship. It died loudly. I'm sorry.
- jrib 5y agoJIRA. For personal stuff, bloated websites just get replaced with less bloated alternatives. At work, I don't have that luxury...
- vsareto 5y agoDefinitely whichever one I'm currently working on
- barbs 5y agoFacebook. Aside from all the obvious privacy problems, the product itself is also ridiculously bloated for what it is.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoDefinitely WageWorks.
- ndury 5y agoI'm surprised Facebook hasn't been mentioned (yet). The mobile application is workable but the desktop version is just awful
- every 5y agoAgreed. If wasn't for near and extended relations who will use nothing else, I would avoid it entirely...
- toastal 5y agoHuh. I guess I forgot about it. My browser has touch.facebook come up if I type in the URL bar and I've basically only used the touch version even on desktop for ages.
- pta2002 5y agoI honestly find the opposite. Facebook's website seems to be one of the best ones of this new SPA trend, and doesn't seem to have any speed issues. The (android) app meanwhile consistently lags for me, and things like voting on polls have a 50/50 chance of working.
- raydev 5y agoSame. I find the app to be actively hostile as its always showing me notification badges for no reason. That new giant F button in the tab bar always has a number on it that disappears when I tap, but there's no obvious content for me to look at there. Desktop FB is pleasant. No fake notification badges.
- darksaints 5y agoLinkedIn, partly because the tech is so bloated and slow and it makes it hard to navigate/search, but also because literally 99% of the site is bloviating self-promotion spam.
- yawnxyz 5y agoI'm always surprised at how terrible Linkedin's design and engineering has been over the years. The latest redesign is definitely very welcome
- bugmen0t 5y agoslack
- max_hammer 5y agoSlack works as website ?
- other_herbert 5y agoAdobe XD for designs/ wireframes... Jira is small in comparison
- debarshri 5y agoI might be naive, fairly new in UI. So my questions are as follows - What does bloated website actually mean? What is characteristics of a bloated website? I could imagine something that bloated for you, might not be bloated for me? Are there any metrics that quantifies this?
- mr_sturd 5y agoVisually, it can be ads taking up large amounts of screen space, making the information that you're looking for a pain to find. In the background, it can be that your browser is making requests to heaps of tracking services and CDNs when loading the page.
- codyb 5y agoAnother example are the poorly optimized websites where each tab uses > 100mb of memory and the all pops new tabs open frequently (I’m looking at you JIRA). I’ve basically just stopped browsing the web at this point. It’s nigh on unusable sometimes. I buy recipe books, read the NYTime’s daily newsletter, and browse hackernews. Reddit’s unbearable these days, Twitter’s a bit of a dumpster fire even if it wasn’t bloated (I don’t have social media accounts to curate the experience either), and god forbid you click a link on a news aggregator site like Fark (where the headlines are as misleading as something your Great Aunt shared from some long chain of disinformation anyways), even with ad blockers half the pages are just absolutely bonkers. It’s just not worth it anymore. My print copy of the New Yorker and occasionally some blog posts from here.
- debarshri 5y agoYou can look at it from a different perspective. I wouldn't mind if an app like figma takes a huge amount of memory. It is comes in my critical professional path. I think if an app falls in your life's critical path, you can look past the memory, cpu usage, bloati-ness etc. I am judging website these days with this kind of yardstick.
- 5y ago
- petercooper 5y agoI don't know if it's really bloated but in terms of feeling terrible, it's Google Cloud's various dashboards. The underlying page loads in reasonably enough, but then everything on top is 'hydrated' on the go and it psychologically feels dragged out, like how pages used to load in the 90s but faster.
- dkarl 5y agoI haven't worked with Google Cloud dashboards much, but I feel like I recognize what you're talking about. I hate pages that load quickly with everything missing and then incrementally load all their components, even if it happens very quickly. As soon as the page comes up, my brain starts fruitlessly working to figure out how to interact with it, while it churns through its transformation into an actual working page. Instead of wasting my attention like that, just be honest and don't ask for my attention until you're ready for it.
- tasubotadas 5y agoGmail.
- rogem002 5y agoI switched to Protonmail as my main email & have been very happy. Every time I go back to check my old Gmail (I use it for signing up to products I know will spam me) I get very irritated at everything.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoThe heaviest website I use is Figma, but for completely understandable reasons—it's a professional piece of design software, which so happens to take the form of a website. A questionable choice, perhaps, but Figma is still relatively performant for what it is.
- Adrig 5y agoReddit by far. I find the old version unappealing but the new is just a dumpster fire. I'm basically dreading any missclick because I'll be stuck for a few seconds. Not to mention the worst video player on the internet. This website's performance is shameful.I would spend easily twice as much time on Reddit as I do right now if it was snappy
- zozos 5y agoMan, I have been soo disappointed by the new Reddit interface. Its terrible.
- cainxinth 5y agoI hate the new version. If they ever kill old.Reddit.com I will be very unhappy.
- nojser 5y agoTeddit.net[0] solves a lot of these problems and paired with Redirector[1], it's a transparent switch out. https://github.com/teddit-net/teddit https://github.com/teddit-net/teddit https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/redirector/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/redirector/
- logicslave 5y agoReddit must just have terrible developers. Like they havent paid them enough and it shows in the product. But its the most popular forum on the internet, so people use it anyways.
- seattle_spring 5y agoThat's what you get when you abolish negotiation. Helps the lowest common denominator, but hurts top talent.
- raydev 5y agoI was rushing to the thread to post this. The new site, even after all this time, is dramatically slower to load content than old.reddit. Does anyone at reddit actually use reddit? Another issue is pretending comment threads are modal?? If I click to read comments, it presents a sheet of comments that if you accidentally click outside them, they just disappear. And they broke the back button, so when you go back to read those comments you accidentally dismissed, you don't land at your previous scroll position.
- Trisell 5y agoI find these days almost any local tv news website to be all but unusable. Between the multiple ad pop ups, multiple auto play videos, and the general clutter. Just trying to read a single news story is an effort that pisses me off to the point where I just close out the tab instead of reading the article.
- coldpie 5y agoInstall an ad blocker, https://ublockorigin.com/ https://ublockorigin.com/
- davedx 5y agoJIRA
- aphextron 5y agohttps://www.lingscars.com https://www.lingscars.com
- colanderman 5y agoFandom. Unfortunately it's the best source for in depth data about several video games I play (notably Civ VI... e.g. here's a random page [1]) but for a website with primarily user-generated text content, it loads a ton of video ads on every single page, making it a bear to use. [1] https://civilization.fandom.com/wiki/Civilizations_(Civ6) https://civilization.fandom.com/wiki/Civilizations_(Civ6)
- coldpie 5y agohttps://ublockorigin.com/ https://ublockorigin.com/
- colanderman 5y agoYou keep making these comments, like HN users don't know that ad blockers exist. These comments are particularly unhelpful in a thread specifically about identifying bloated websites.
- coldpie 5y agoBlocking ads is good for users, good for the Internet, and good for society, so I evangelize for it as much as I can.
- chomp 5y agoGCP. I don’t know what it’s doing under the hood but it’s such a slog loading it up and waiting for the UI to settle before I can actually do something.
- new_here 5y agoJIRA is unrivalled in my opinion. Just loaded up a random ticket page with one comment and no attachments. - 105 requests - 3.9MB transferred - 13.9MB resources - 32.57s load time Here's a nice repo of other examples: https://github.com/dominictarr/your-web-app-is-bloated https://github.com/dominictarr/your-web-app-is-bloated
- i_haz_rabies 5y agoSince JIRA has already been thoroughly excoriated, I'll go with The Athletic. It used to have a brilliant, simple UI. Now, it takes forever to load and when I click, the UI will magically shift and I will end up clicking an ad.
- darepublic 5y agoGlassdoor seems bloated to me.
- igetspam 5y agoSome sites are bad but I use them so little that they don't matter. For instance, USAA shipped my 529 to another company and their site is trash. It's heavy and broken. I login once a month though, so it doesn't matter much. Slack and GMail I have open all the time. Slack is by far the worst of the two but they both consume a ton of resources. I'd probably be more annoyed by GMail if the UX was as bad as Slack though. Then there's any atlassian product. Slow, confusing, constantly changing for the worse. There was a time in my life when I used both daily and they weren't that bad. Now I use a slack bot to interact with jira and and make one edit in confluence a day (for a standup and it takes about three minutes to edit, update and save). And reddit... If I had to rely on that daily I'd probably rage quit the internet. I still use the old interface for most things. It's ugly but it's not a dumpster fire of slow loading API calls to render bloat.
- TheAdamAndChe 5y agoUSAA's new 529 company is absolutely horrible. Has arbitrary password length limits. It complains of good, complex passwords and you can't paste them in. I couldn't even log in because my account became locked. It definitely hurt USAA's reputation for me.
- Jtsummers 5y agoIs it actually USAA's 529 company still or is it like other investments that got shipped to Schwab and you can just click through USAA's site to get to it now? I kind of understand their desire to separate these divisions and focus on insurance and (I suppose still) core banking, but I really miss having a singular place to log into and access the bulk of my financial activity and data. EDIT: Seems they farmed their 529 plans out to Victory Capital. Going directly to their site they only seem to support: financial professionals, institutional investors, and USAA individual investors. Which suggests, to me, the problem. They aren't really set up to deal with individuals. At least Schwab already dealt with individual investors so my brokerage account and IRAs weren't screwed with too much.
- throwaddzuzxd 5y agoI hate to say it because I love it, but GitLab. When I'm on a repository, the sidebar has 5 items that I don't use and cannot remove (Github in comparison lets me hide almost anything I don't use: discussions, issues, wiki...). Issues are bloated and nothing can be hidden: designs, linked issues, votes, comments, right sidebar with todo, assignees, time tracking, due date, labels, weight (even though the feature is "locked"), confidentiality, status and references. That's true on every single page on Gitlab: tons of great stuff hidden between things that I don't use. I love that Gitlab has so many features, but I hate that I cannot cherry pick what I actually use to cleanup the UI.
- MvRemmerden 5y agoGitLab Product Design Manager here Thanks for your feedback! You bring up quite a few great points. We have worked hard on bringing every tool from the DevOps lifecycle into our platform, and I agree with you that quite a few areas have become overwhelming, especially for new users or people who don't use our entire set of features. We are actively working on refining that, but as you can imagine, that's no easy feat, as we have a vast variety of project types, workflows, use cases, user types, etc... One of the most problematic areas, as you perfectly mentioned, is the left sidebar. We already enable project administrators to remove items from there by going to Settings -> General -> Visibility, project features, permissions, and then toggling off the areas you would like to remove. However, this is a project setting, not per user. At the same time, we also work on making that left sidebar better for everyone, in multiple smaller iterations. As first step, we are making some small changes to the visual design (https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab/-/issues/322680 https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab/-/issues/322680) and make the navigation easier to understand (https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab/-/issues/322687 https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab/-/issues/322687). We are also aware that our left sidebar has become too crowded with too many top-level/sub-level items, and we are validating an idea that would be the first step for us to get out of this (https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/ux-research/-/issues/1421 https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/ux-research/-/issues/1421). There are already a few follow-up ideas (e.g. grouping items into larger groups or pinning most important items per user), but they are a bit further away. I hope that gives you a better understanding how our UX team at GitLab thinks about this. Let me know if you have any other feedback or ideas
- Jemm 5y agohttps://www.cbc.ca/news https://www.cbc.ca/news
- beautifulfreak 5y agoIMDB has been getting slower and slower with feature bloat, to the extent I avoid it for doing movie-info searches. Thankfully there's a nice app for that I wish more people knew about: Coollector. https://www.coollector.com https://www.coollector.com
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- yesenadam 5y agoThe IMDb website just changed to look a lot like the mobile app, and I've noticed it's worse in dozens of ways already. Everything takes more clicks than before, and is harder to read. More whitespace, more bloat.
- IdontRememberIt 5y agoTripadvisor beats them all: I have been using it since its beginning (amazing product and amazing competitive advantage over other travelers). Today, it is a hall of fame of all the direct marketing tricks, black hat seo technics, anti-patterns, external javascript from everywhere, etc. Also, its information is so diffused and played that it does not provide extraordinary advantage. Thanks to covid, I have not visited it this last 1.5 year.
- kevincox 5y agoGoogle Drive. It is a file listing, there is no excuse for a folder not loading nearly instantly. Furthermore they make it feel even slower by requiring double clicks and breaking basic features such as copying the URL or opening in a new tab. Whenever I use the drive file browser I miss Apache directory listings.
- CarelessExpert 5y agoConfluence. A truly hot mess of an SPA-style website. Literally >10 second page load times with hundreds and hundreds of API calls to populate a page. To show a document. Literally the very thing the web was created for. It's honestly astounding how bad it is.
- robjan 5y agoAtlassian products: Jira, Bitbucket and Confluence. They are the tools I use the most and they bog my computer right down especially when connected to a corporate proxy which only supports HTTP 1.
- codegeek 5y ago-Reddit (The new one) - JIRA (Need I say more) - AWS new UI: For some reason, recent changes by AWS in their UI/Console is terrible. When I open S3, the buckets now take few seconds to appear compared to before when it was instant. The number of buckets are similar. WTF AWS.
- valbaca 5y agoSummarizing: - JIRA - Reddit - Twitter - AWS - GCP - Slack - Gmail - News - Recipes
- seattle_spring 5y agoEvery single recipe site.
- qq4 5y agogmail
- jgwil2 5y agoAny news site, but foxnews.com is one of the worst. On top of everything almost every article has some auto-playing video that follows you as you scroll.
- muzani 5y agoFacebook. What does it do? Chat (for adults and kids), dating, blogging, marketplace, groups, stories, AR, image recognition, live feeds, YouTube-style videos, shopping, property rentals, Q&A, clubhouse-style rooms, COVID-19 info center, multiplayer gaming community, events, job listings, mental health, weather, fundraising. I avoid the app because I think it's data harvesting, but the mobile site is such a pain. Sometimes it's the little things like writing "the..." in the text box, and accidentally tagging "Theodore" because of a generic word. I have to type all my Facebook comments in a separate text editor.
- xtiansimon 5y agoADP. Aggg. Slllloooowwww. Payroll, so naturally there is a gate.
- sershe 5y agoChase bank banking. What an unbelievable bloated animated JavaScript monstrosity... I do my bills once a month, so I open chase side by side with all the other tabs, and it's like - click a button in chase, pay one entire credit card/mortgage/check account history/whatever in the other window while it's loading. I usually have time for everything and sometimes even to research and do my option trades in the time it takes to check and pay 3 cards with chase. Cancelling chase sapphire soon in part because of that (I have another similar fee card with a normal site), and stopping the use of another no-fee card purely because of the site. If we ever interview someone who worked on this atrocity I'd have to recuse myself :)
- grumpy-cowboy 5y agoGoogle Cloud Platform (GCP) web console : really slow and take HUGE amount of memory
- readonthegoapp 5y agoGmail
- zodiakzz 5y agoAliExpress and Alibaba Dell/HP driver download sites