4 ms·
> What if society really appreciated its essential workers and compensated them like it did? The person I was responding to was arguing against compensation as
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
> What if society really appreciated its essential workers and compensated them like it did?
The person I was responding to was arguing against compensation as a concept in general.
- grasshopperpurp 5y agoVery fair. I don't think you can remove compensation. But, I think the post still had some good thoughts and good aims. They need some tweaking. Your post highlighted an area that needs tweaking, and mine tried to build on both posts.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThat tweak is a universal basic income (or other broad based benefits that establish a floor for quality of life) which would attempt to reduce the impact of one's lineage on one's options.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoWhat if monetary or material compensation was replaced with simple respect and appreciation though? As it is, the people who do the dirty jobs of society are often treated like they themselves are filth.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThen we would not be living in the same world with the same parameters as we are now.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoAnd yet there are functional societies out there today, much as there were in the past, that are not capitalistic societies. Treating people like shit and forcing them to do dirty jobs you don't want to do under threat of starvation is not an inherent property of the human condition.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhich societies operated like that? I am not aware of any, that could operate as a country of decent size today. Note that this supposed country would also need to be able to defend itself, if it has possession of anything valuable (such as water, arable land, weather, etc). And also be able to deal with immigration and outsiders coming in, and kicking out people who would mess up the system.
- silicon2401 5y agoWhat kind of idealistic misunderstanding of history do you have that non-capitalist societies were some kumbaya utopia? Korea historically had slavery and extreme class differences. Europe had nobility and serfs who were not far off from slaves (and could be tortured or executed). Ancient Sparta and Persia had slaves and going way back into biblical times (though this still happens today in some places), people could be stoned just for not believing the right things. People today make the mistake of assuming things were altogether better in the past just because one particular aspect they dislike today was better before. Hierarchy and treating each other terribly are an inherent part of being human, and it's taken centuries of work to get to a point that we can even pretend otherwise.
- andrepd 5y agoHe said some non-capitalist societies, not all non-capitalist societies that have ever existed.
- silicon2401 5y agoWhich makes it a moot point. The common thread across capitalist, socialist, monarchist, whatever-ist societies with suffering is that humans are involved. Neither capitalism nor socialism is inherently bad; some humans are, especially in aggregate, hence we always need ways to enforce order. The fatal flaw to any utopian society is that the more it depends on trust, the more some people will abuse it and coordinate with others to abuse it. The less trust you have, the more force you need to enforce your worldview on others (which radical liberals and conservatives essentially push for). There is no magical world where we all live in harmony
- curation 5y agoHave you read Another Tomorrow by Yanis Varafoufakis?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoNo.
- haskellandchill 5y agoThe title is Another Now, thanks for the rec!