6 ms·
Microsoft Teams Calls will soon include end-to-end encryption
- cybert00th 5y agoWhat!? It didn't before!? I want my money back! Oh, wait...
- imglorp 5y agohttp://web.archive.org/web/20210603101816/https://techplanet.today/post/microsoft-teams-calls-will-soon-include-end-to-end-encryption http://web.archive.org/web/20210603101816/https://techplanet... In a related note, Skype had peer-to-peer and encryption back in the day, before MS bought them and centralized it. What's next for Teams, p2p?
- thrower123 5y agoGiven the way Teams is architected, I highly doubt that.
- velgewp 5y agoNow-er-days encryption has become a marketing phenomenon by the tech gaints...
- gota 5y agoIt's mind boggling how many features Teams Calls are missing. It still does not have an "annotate" tool. Other features are good-to-have, but not being able to point things out in a shared screen is a deal breaker for remote work collaboration.
- imglorp 5y agoAnnotation is a killer collaboration feature! Zoom has it but it's awkward. Slack has a very convenient crayon that just works most of the time and is nice for quickly pointing at things, but Slack calls still seem iffy sometimes. Who else has annotation?
- apercu 5y agoThe biggest issue I have with Teams, Zoom, Hangouts is that I have to use all three in the course of the day and I can never find anything (mute, share, etc.) because they all have different design patterns (which change seemingly with every other release) so I end up hanging up on calls when I want to unmute myself.
- jpeter 5y agoI can't wait when I can reply to a specific message on the desktop app
- gota 5y agoYou can format your post as a "quote", but that doesn't give you a true-pointer (e.g. you cant click the quote to go to the post, like in a Watsapp or Slack reply) To add insult to injury its very clunky to quote and respond in the same post. You have to paste the text you're going to quote, then hit return and type your answer and only after select the text and press "quote" in the rich editor If you don't follow that particular order everything (including your response) becomes part of the quote. I'm ranting, but seems such a trivial thing to get right that it bothers me. And I need it everyday
- wisam 5y agoJust type > before pasting the quoted text. But you have type some text in a separate line as a place holder of your own response before you paste your quote or else your response will be part of the quote as you just said.
- gota 5y agoYes, that's exactly the issue! In Slack I can type > to quote something, and a line break will continue the quote. However, pressing backspace returns to normal text In Teams you're stuck on quote-mode Notice that in Slack I don't need to use quotes for replies, as the reply-to-message works Retraction as I write this after some intensive googling: apparently pushing shift+Enter twice in teama breaks you out of quote mode. So at least there's that.
- dancemethis 5y agoIf people believe it... It's their loss.
- swiley 5y agoIt's end to end encryption, but the same small set of companies completely own both ends so it doesn't matter.
- lume 5y agoAs soon as NSA finishes installing the backdoor.
- gmaster1440 5y agoAnd yet still no apple silicon optimized builds where slack and zoom have offered for months.
- ekianjo 5y agoOptimizing an electron client ? Will still be a resource hog at the end of the day.
- smolyeet 5y agoThey don't even have an Intel Mac optimized version and we just got big sur icons. Relax, they're a small indie company
- capableweb 5y agoIs "apple silicon optimized builds" somehow required for E2E encryption or how is this comment related to the submission itself? General comments about product X just because it's mentioned in the submission feels pretty boring.
- gmaster1440 5y agoSorry that you're not entertained. While obviously not a requirement for encryption, my comment is designed to draw attention to what's becoming a pattern of Microsoft not focusing on much needed performance improvements and instead continuing to layer new features on top of a shaky core experience.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tclancy 5y agoHeck, I'd settle for one that could take focus reliably and consistently when changing between screens. There's some stupid invisible "Microsoft Teams Notification" it always focuses to instead. And it never bothers to drop me directly into the chat window when I do manage to focus it.
- sandworm101 5y agoEnd to end, but to which ends? I seriously doubt that MS will cut itself off. There are too many reasons (national security response, marketing, police investigations etc) for them to keep at least some access to content in extremis. The "end" will be some midpoint within MS systems or control.
- Yizahi 5y agoAlso empty words are one thing and deeds are another. We can look at MS past actions which already happened, and one of them was - the first thing they did after buying Skype was to disable p2p calls which they couldn't intercept, and reworked app architecture to centralized.
- lucgommans 5y agoI wonder if they'll make it unverifiable (like Keybase[1]), opportunistic (like WhatsApp[2]), requiring confirmation in every call so nobody practically uses it (like Telegram[3]), hide the key verification screen so 0.001% practically does it (like Signal[4]), uses long-lived keys that can decrypt all historical traffic (like PGP), have encrypted mode be some second-rate mode that removes most of the features you need (like Telegram's encrypted chats; I see that the announcement already mentions some unavailable features when you turn on encryption), or if they'll have a novel trick to break the encryption at will. At a minimum, I expect it'll be an obfuscated binary with auto-updates and no published independent code reviews. Let's hope Microsoft surprises us all! (as I see most of the comments being skeptical) [1] Try to verify which encryption keys your mobile keybase chat client is using or if the server injected its own keys. Bonus points if you spot the "this chat is end-to-end encrypted" banner while you're doing this. Details: https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/222055/how-can-i-verify-keybases-end-to-end-encryption-between-me-and-a-friend https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/222055/how-can-... [2] You have to go into settings to enable even just seeing key changes, let alone that the client stops you from sending messages when a previously verified key changes. [3] Telegram calls have encryption, but every time you have to verify the emojis again and again instead of it just storing the other party's key. [4] Threema shows the verification status for every chat. My mother in law, from her own volition, wanted to verify keys with me. She later tried Signal to compare, since she needs to use something encrypted for her work (medical data), but didn't get that she had to verify keys on Signal, too. I find that even techies often don't know where to find that in Signal, or even realize that it's required for the security claims to apply.
- Spooky23 5y agoI doubt it, that’s not the kind of feature that Teams customers want. Most businesses have a need for discovery and audit, and Teams is a phone application with lawful interception needs, so you’re always going to have an interception capability. End of the day, it’s a way to sell the full Microsoft stack… the only way to have an E2E encrypted meeting is to not allow dial-in, which is a way to encourage adoption of Teams as a unified communication solution. (Which is the strategy Zoom is attempting as well)
- uncletammy 5y agoSpeaking of Microsoft and encryption, here's a fun little clip from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_(surveillance_program) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_(surveillance_program) > According to The Guardian, NSA had access to chats and emails on Hotmail.com and Skype because Microsoft had "developed a surveillance capability to deal" with the interception of chats, and "for Prism collection against Microsoft email services will be unaffected because Prism collects this data prior to encryption." Fool me once, shame on me...
- papito 5y agoIt's as real as the Chupacabra or log-less VPN.
- Havoc 5y agoTeams is already so slow and bloated. It’s damn near unusable even or fairly new hardware (eg surface 7 pro). More encryption overhead is the last thing i need on that front
- Clewza313 5y agoI'm not going to complain about Teams in a world where WebEx still exists.
- duckfang 5y agoI've refused going on WebEx calls and claim technical reasons why it doesnt work. ANYTHING is better than Webex. Even smoke signals over IP is better.
- sangupta 5y agoGood to see Microsoft competing with Apple. Teams already kills an i9 octa-core 32GB Macbook ensuring fans max out, this will ensure they can kill the next MBP launching soon.
- linuxdaemon 5y agoWhen I am in a video chat, glances reports teams taking between 120% and 140% of the CPU. that's when I'm passive participant not even sharing my camera.
- villgax 5y agoUntil the Indian govt deems it not be the case.....sadly
- martini333 5y agoHow is this not just a default when making software?
- sneak 5y agoMicrosoft was the very first partner in the NSA's PRISM surveillance program (the #1 used source in US intelligence reports!) that allows the US federal government access to stored communications in Microsoft servers (think Skype, Hotmail, MSN messenger) directly and without a warrant, for any user on the service. It now includes all major US providers, but MS was first, and all of the administration and planning of the surveillance programs themselves happens in Microsoft software, on Windows. The Snowden PRISM slides are screenshots of PowerPoint. Microsoft is as integrated in the global surveillance apparatus as anyone possibly could be. Making products that don't advance the US global surveillance programs and national interest would be to bite the hand that feeds them.
- aleks224 5y agoThe article mentions Teams E2EE in the context of password sharing between employees. Also E2EE will be an opt-in thing, but a company may enable it by default for all 1:1 calls. Sounds like this is mostly about companies believing to be more secure if their employees share passwords only with E2EE enabled.
- andred14 5y agoLOL. I would not trust Microsoft to park my car for me so you won't see me using this.
- brokenmachine 5y agoEnd to end encrypted, completely secure from your end to NSA end.