3 ms·
The Bac was a tool of neutral advancement but I really don’t think it has been in decades. SAT has a more mixed history and has never been particularly neutral
by gumby 5y ago
The Bac was a tool of neutral advancement but I really don’t think it has been in decades. SAT has a more mixed history and has never been particularly neutral (more like am IQ test). Gao Kao has a very long and mixed record but I agree that for a long time it was at least intended to be neutral. But the “princelings” (太子黨) show how neutral it really is today.
Personally I take a dim view of the utility of any test that can be crammed for.
> I don't think you can argue that a society built on admitting based on diversity rather than even imperfect standardized testing can be more independent of the pre-existing network.
Certainly you can, and I am not only citing such an argument and agreeing with it, but am such an example. It’s hardly perfect of course.
But just for myself: I am genetically a “mongrel” (per the then laws of the country of my birth), my father was the only of his siblings to enter university; their parents had finished only grades 3 and 6. My mother of a race normally banned from the country. Zero status there.
But I attended what is at times described as the “best”* high school in the USA and the so-called “best” university due in part to great SAT scores. (Note: almost four decades ago!). So the system can work. Those with preexisting networks will still have an advantage, but I gained access to them too. I suppose you could say I traveled to the USA so I was inherently in some sort of “in group”.
I don’t remember that there was any SAT prep in those days though perhaps it was just not available to me. I certainly don’t remember any of my schoolmates studying for it.
* quotation marks because I consider such unidimensional claims to be fatuous. Mentioning them simply to supply a real world example.