5 ms·
A person in 2011 who has never used a computer has far more serious issues (or "differences") to the way they approach life than you can solve by redesigning me
by ck2 15y ago
A person in 2011 who has never used a computer has far more serious issues (or "differences") to the way they approach life than you can solve by redesigning menus and layout.
This would be like approaching someone in their teens who still cannot read and trying to design a book you are writing to be more accessible to them instead of your general readership.
It's simply a matter of hand-on, over time. I've converted a few AOL users over the years to Firefox, etc. and there is absolutely nothing you can do to improve their experience beyond a very basic level. They just have to use it for a year and go through their own trial-and-error of learning.
- Meai 15y agoHis point was hardly that we should design interfaces for computer illiterates, but that a person who has never used a computer may provide valuable information on how humans try to approach new interfaces in general. This information can help us put emphasis on the right things: Instead of a bunch of buttons, concise text that leads the user. I imagine something like "Your first time using Internet Explorer? Click -here- to get more information." would have helped him greatly. (not in this particular situation, but if he were at home with his newly bought computer and properly invested in his pursuit of email, then yes.)
- illdave 15y agoExactly. I've, perhaps foolishly, designed mock-ups and interfaces before where I've used icons instead of text explaining what it is, and I'd often think to myself "It's ok - people will probably click around to learn what that does". That's probably wishful thinking on my part.
- digamber_kamat 15y agoWell there are millions such people in India and they are a big market.
- roel_v 15y agoNo they're not, because they're the people who don't have a cent to spend, and if they do they'll spend it on food. There are millions who do have some money, but those already know how phones, computers etc. work.
- andos 15y agoPeople are not upright beasts whose only needs are food and shelter. People also might be perfectly well fed and healthy, but live in rural areas, or be elderly, or have learning disabilities. People who were once very poor can start receiving extra income (and that is particularly true in the BRIC countries) and gain access to computers. People interact with new interfaces all the time, and not all user interaction occurs with a computer. So, there definitely is a market for those complete novices. Regardless, understanding how people interact with new interfaces for the first time is interesting. Joe's case is only a single instance of this situation (and perhaps extreme, given the context). Every time a new interaction model is developed, the insights from such an experiment might prove useful.
- digamber_kamat 15y agoYour argument is logical but you see you are wrong. There is something about human beings that makes them act un-rationally. Many Indians who live on less that $2 a day own mobile phones. Coca Cola and Pepsi realized that they need to trap this market hence they decided to come up with very small bottles that cost around half of a normal drink bottle and this strategy got them millions. Similarly for stuff like Shampoo, ice cream and so on. Same thing can be applied to electronic items as well.
- doyoulikeworms 15y agoThis is not necessarily irrational, but a different expression of relative preference compared to the "most sensible" case. The reason I say this is because you cannot define a "rational" set of relative preferences. It is hard to say whether or not someone insanely frugal like Sam Walton is acting rationally or not, for example. Irrational behavior, in this context, could be that someone does value food over phones, but somehow ends up constantly buying phones to his misfortune. Not the same as someone who actually values phones over food.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- narcissus 15y agoAlthough I am all for user experience testing, I also agree with you on this point. To be perfectly honest, my first thought when reading this was "well that's not really fair, as imagine the sorts of things that user would have learned before they even got to the browser?". That is to say, if they were brand new to the computer, they would have had to have learned enough to find the browser and run it, first, before the time where this user started. The things the user learned may very well have changed the reactions inside of the browser. Even so, it's still a great article, as I think sometimes that 'first-time user experience' can also translate to 'new to English user experience', too.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- rm445 15y agoThe way he floundered looking for somewhere to get started was quite instructive. I've used several programs over the years that would have really benefitted from a UI element that indicated 'click here if you have no idea how this program works', and that took you to useful help. Not every aspect of a program has to be designed for beginners. But having just one clear item to get people started might be a boon. It doesn't have to assume no knowledge of computers; perhaps just no knowledge of the problem domain or the particular program's workflow.
- rospaya 15y agoSome people just don't have the need for a computer, I don't see why that would be a problem if they are happy with how they're life is going without it.