5 ms·
The Lab-Leak Mess
- aphroz 5y ago"The mass man produced in this way must be treated as what he is: a calf, and he must be kept a close eye on, as a herd should be. Anything that allays his lucidity is good socially, and anything that could awaken it must be ridiculed, stifled and fought. Any doctrine questioning the system must first be designated as subversive and terrorist, and those who support it must then be treated as such." Günther Anders Edit: this is not an extract of the article
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Leary 5y agoIf it was lab leaked, how come Italy had infections by September 2019? [1] [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/health-coronavirus-italy-timing/researchers-find-coronavirus-was-circulating-in-italy-earlier-than-thought-idUSKBN27W1J2 https://www.reuters.com/article/health-coronavirus-italy-tim...
- sampo 5y agoThere is a lot of Chinese immigrants working in the fashion and textile industry in those areas in Northern Italy, with frequent flight connections to Wuhan, which is also a hub for fashion and textile industry.
- ramraj07 5y agoMaybe it was leaked earlier? How does this support either narrative?
- nsoonhui 5y agoIf Italy really had infections as early as September 2019, then why Wuhan-- and not Italy-- was the singular point where the Covid 19 pandemic started? Ultimately, whether Italy had infections before Wuhan couldn't tell us anything about the origin.
- abecedarius 5y agoIt seems plausible for all the evidence for very early infections elsewhere to be just mistaken. But if it is right it does contradict the hypothesis.
- tayo42 5y agoRepublicans made a huge mess by politicizing everything. This article in the first line starts by assigning blame to "liberals" (like liberals are one entity?) Americans voted in chaos and got their chaos. If we had leaders we could trust, and weren't turning every little thing into a political game with two sides pitted against each other we wouldn't have a media that's already primed to be calling out that administrations constant bullshit. I don't know how else you could have expected anyone to act? We don't trust you, and now in hindsight we were all expected to put trust in a theory that came with a side of racism? Boy who cried wolf in real life, it has consequences as we see. If you want to root cause the mess you need to look at why the media responded the way it did and not at the response of the media and the public it self.
- sampo 5y agoOutsider perspective: American media went crazy. American perspective: We hate the other half of our own country, so we need our media to be crazy. It's all for a good cause.
- tayo42 5y ago> Outsider perspective: American media went crazy. It absolutely did, we need to step back and figure out why and address those problems.
- mnouquet 5y ago> American media went crazy Still are.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- enaaem 5y agoThe problem wasn’t the media. I accept that media can be biased as long as all sides can say their thing. The problem is with the social media fact checkers who have to decide what’s wrong or right. Information was removed without scientific evidence that it was clearly wrong.
- 5y ago
- haberman 5y ago> A given theory can be a conspiracy and racist and, at root, true, just as a given theory can be scientifically grounded and not racist and, at root, false; who is propounding it, and why, and based on what, matters. Truth is an absolute defense against charges of libel and slander, but not, apparently, against the charge of racism.
- loopz 5y agoRacism is too cheap these days, as it often speaks of intentions hard to prove. You may call it bad faith though.
- wearywanderer 5y agoOn the bright side, this contains an acknowledgement that 'conspiracy' is not actually synonymous with falsehood. The meanings of "conspiracy theory" according Wiktionary, my favorite dictionary: > 1. A hypothesis alleging that the members of a coordinated group are, and/or were, secretly working together to commit illegal or wrongful actions including attempting to hide the existence of the group and its activities. In notable cases the hypothesis contradicts the mainstream explanation for historical or current events. [1960s] The first sentence describes something that certainly does happen. Organized crime syndicates are conspiracies. If somebody tries to hire a hitman to kill their neighbor, they'll be charged with conspiracy to commit murder. Conspiracies are real things that sometimes happen. The second sentence is where things get interesting. As far as I've been able to determine, this started with the assassination of JFK. Officially, he was killed by a single man who acted on his own and didn't conspire with anybody else. Any theory that posits the gunman was in cahoots with anybody else was a conspiracy theory in the original sense the term. In the aftermath of that, 'conspiracy theory' seemingly became mixed up with the premise of disagreeing with the mainstream explanation. But sometimes the mainstream narrative is a theory about people conspiring. The man who shot Lincoln conspired with others; that's the mainstream narrative in that case and I have no reason to doubt it. It's all very tiresome.
- bosswipe 5y agoThe most important term in that definition is "hypothesis", which is a hunch based on little evidence. Why have I suddenly been seeing a bunch of internet comments like yours trying to rehabilitate "conspiracy theory"? Is there some conservative influencer promoting this?
- null_object 5y agoGenuine question: I read this article, and then read parts of it again, and I’m still not sure what it’s trying to add to the current discourse on the lab-accident theory?
- hvs 5y agoAs it is in the Columbia Journalism Review in their "The Media Today" section, I think it is quite simply summarizing the situation for their readers.
- messo 5y agoA refreshingly honest and inquisitive summary of the topic. I have hardly followed the debackle, only heard some arguments for and against through others. This look like journalism to me, reporting with a great deal of uncertainty and not faling for the temptation to write as if you have all the answers: «To my mind, staking out the proper boundary between science and politics has been the defining journalistic challenge of the pandemic; it might well be impossible to pinpoint, though we could, collectively, have been more thoughtful about looking, and the errors around the lab-leak reflect that failure. The path forward on that story is the same as it always should have been: cover the context, respect the uncertainty, and report out the underpinning truth; China’s lack of transparency may make this impossible, too, but it remains the goal. »