4 ms·
A HVDC cable from Sahara to NY would loose 20%, but solar is 33% more intense in a Sahara. Basically it saves on overnight batteries and is a hedge against weat
by dzhiurgis 5y ago
A HVDC cable from Sahara to NY would loose 20%, but solar is 33% more intense in a Sahara. Basically it saves on overnight batteries and is a hedge against weather and other factors.
Also as solar install itself is around 50% of its cost, it's probably cheaper to do so in a dessert in a country with low labour cost than over your house.
Dunno how to run the numbers tho. I'm sure it's relatively simple.
Edit:
Grid scale solar "levelized cost of energy" is 30-40 $/MWH, or 36-48 $/MWH if you account for losses across ocean (3.5% per 1000km).
Cost of HVDC cable, based on Singapore link - 4,500km @ 3GW - $5.6b. Western Sahara to NY 5,600km = $7b.
Wastern Sahara gives you 5.250 kWh/kWp per day. I now need to calculate how much power can you pipe thru the lifetime of the cable. Then compare that with grid scale batteries.
15.75 GWH per day or 172 TWH per 30 years.
$7b/172twh = $0.04 / kwh for transmission, excluding maintenance.
Battery storage is 115-150$/MWH or 0.115-0.15 $/KWH. So kinda looks it's cheaper to have HVDC.
- erentz 5y agoNational security implications of relying on such a cable strung across an ocean to power your economy seem quite large.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoThis is de-risking. Also it’s a minuscule percentage right now.
- chmod775 5y agoThat ship has sailed long ago. I doubt there's a country on earth that could protect all of its critical infrastructure against another nation with modern weaponry and tactics. I wouldn't count on either country having much in the way of an energy grid left after a week or so. Additionally war will disrupt supply chains for a lot of industries, stuff you need for power grids included. This is a popular example to illustrate how little it would take to cripple a nation's power grid: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metcalf_sniper_attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metcalf_sniper_attack Don't even need fancy long range missiles as long as you have clandestine operators in the target country. In a discussion of this (on HN I think) someone pointed out that replacements for these transformers probably has to be ordered from Europe, which can take as long as a year.
- Johnythree 5y agoThe answer is redundancy. Eventually there will be a complex network of cables which reach around the world.