3 ms·
There's an evo-psy theory which says that humor originated in the relief we feel when something we perceive is threatening turns out not to be. The boggart turn
by bitwize 5y ago
There's an evo-psy theory which says that humor originated in the relief we feel when something we perceive is threatening turns out not to be. The boggart turns into something innocuous, and we laugh at the thing that started to scare us but failed.
- idiotsecant 5y agoWhich makes an awful lot of sense! Its a pretty effective way of 'infecting' others with the knowledge that the situation is not dangerous without the burden of having to develop a language.
- neilv 5y agoThat's an interesting theory. A related-sounding interesting one I heard (in Marvin Minsky's class, as part of a larger model of the human mind) is that the humor response might have evolved to encourage the brain to identify nonsense, and to inhibit learning of nonsense. I guess that that the learning aspect could fit even better with primitive threat identification than with general learning? (What inputs initially seemed like a threat, turned out not to be, so don't over-learn from initial mistaken emotional reaction to that incident that "inputs => threat"? Or have the enjoyable "good" of the eventual reaction counteract the initial "bad" reaction in primitive learning?) (I'm not representing the theory well, and I know very little of whatever applicable psych/cogsci research.)
- mod 5y agoOff-topic, but I want to ask because you seem like someone who might have heard a theory: Why do we appreciate beauty? As in natural beauty. A sunset, a rolling field, the stars, a colorful flower, etc.
- neilv 5y agoI'm sorry I don't recall at the moment (4am break from work :) what Minsky said about that. His last book was: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emotion_Machine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emotion_Machine (Incidentally, it's a huge loss that Minsky is no longer with us, but I'm glad I got a chance to at least take his class before he passed. Each session, he'd just talk about what he had been working on earlier that day, for The Emotion Machine. One of his PhD students, Push Singh (a great person, who tragically passed way too soon, after an injury), once told me a significant part of his studies was simply talking with Minsky, and Push thought that was pretty great. He also once mentioned that Minsky wanted 10-year grad students, when the norm in the lab was maybe 4-5. I suppose we can still be inspired by some of Minsky's scholarly practices and endless curiosity, as we can find and make the time.) Also, I'm sure others on HN know much more of the science and philosophy of natural beauty than the tidbits I do, and this seems like it could be a good "Ask HN". Maybe not just look at natural beauty, but also human beauty, and music? (An evolutionary basis for a sense of beauty of the human face and form seems too obvious. But maybe there are related simple evolutionary explanations for some of natural beauty, like attraction to advantageous settings and resources? Or maybe it's less obvious, like music?)
- gradschool 5y agoAn unsentimental and slightly creepy theory if you like that kind of thing is that both humor and aesthetic sensibilities evolved as a group defense against psychopathy. Some species including ours gain an advantage among competing species through co-operation among themselves. A species using this strategy is vulnerable to freeloaders within its ranks who optimize their own survival at the expense of the group. The theory goes that an empathy deficit in individuals correlates with other deficits (e.g., in a sense of humor) that might be harder for the individual to hide and therefore easier for the group to detect. By ostracizing the psychopath on that basis, the group increases its overall fitness.
- zengargoyle 5y agoThanks, I had that humor idea rolling around in my mind since the early 90's strong AI era but had forgotten where I read it. Minsky sounds about right. Humor is a forced reset of a failed prediction model, reality does not conform to prediction, shake up that snowglobe of a mind and let reality rewrite prediction. Strengthening bad predictions isn't a good idea for survival.
- natmaka 5y agoI feel threatened => I immediately (without any analyzis) "threaten back" by showing my teeth (beware, I will bite you!). Then I understand there is no threat, and I disguise this first (inadequate) instinctive reaction by transmuting it into something which progressively became recognized as a smile/laugh. There is another similar theory about a dog barking and running at his master because he didn't reckon him as such (many dogs are short sighted), then understanding his mistake and also transmuting this aggressive instinctive response into a "dance" (barking at and standing up towards his master).
- ahazred8ta 5y ago"We do not joke," said Nessus. "My species has no sense of humor." "Strange. I would have thought that humor was an aspect of intelligence." "No. Humor is associated with an interrupted defense mechanism." "All the same--" "Speaker, no sapient being ever interrupts a defense mechanism." -- Ringworld
- jjk166 5y agoConsidering there are many things we find humorous but never find threatening and many cases where we are relieved but don't find anything humorous, that theory seems dubious. A better explanation would be that we laugh at contradictions so as to signal to others that we recognize the contradictions. This both serves to demonstrate our intelligence and social skills (someone who gets jokes quickly comes off as smart and gregarious, the person who doesn't laugh seems either slow or weird), as well as to communicate information (if you laugh at someone who breaks a social rule, they very quickly learn the rule. You laugh at children doing dumb stuff, as well as friends and family, but random adults doing the same thing just appear sad). Especially in a pre-linguistic society, this ability to convey information is extremely important, and analogues can be seen in many species.