4 ms·
> Mp3 is painfully obvious on crappy, processed-to-hell speaker systems like the iMac. I didn't know that was the case. Do you know why that somehow accentuate
by crazygringo 5y ago
> Mp3 is painfully obvious on crappy, processed-to-hell speaker systems like the iMac.
I didn't know that was the case. Do you know why that somehow accentuates MP3 artifacts? It's not obvious to me why it would, since all the processing iMac speakers might perform is high-quality (no recompression involved). I mean, obviously the iMac isn't going to improve the MP3, it just tries to improve the speakers. But why would that make artifacts more noticeable?
If anything, don't "crappy" speakers hide MP3 artifacts, because they're not good enough to expose them?
- vnorilo 5y agoMp3 relies on the fact that loud sounds mask spectrally and temporally adjacent softer sounds (psychoacoustic masking) and allows the noise floor to rise for some bands in such conditions to reduce the required number of bits to encode the band signal. Now if the masking sound disappears or changes, the crap is no longer masked. In other words the psychoacoustic principles work only when we don't alter the signal too much after the codec. Many diminutive speakers make use of techniques like multiband compression (dynamics, not entropy) to produce "larger" sound. That wreaks havoc on the psychoacoustic model of lossy codecs.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]