3 ms·
Much like tying insurance to employment, tying immigration to employment is an awful system. It's fine if you want to require someone to have a job to move her
by jedberg 5y ago
Much like tying insurance to employment, tying immigration to employment is an awful system.
It's fine if you want to require someone to have a job to move here, but that requirement should disappear quickly. Make the employer guarantee to pay them for a year, and allow them to stay once that year is up. That would be a humane way to do it.
It's so terrible that immigrants to this country have to live in constant fear of deportation if they don't have a job.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> It's fine if you want to require someone to have a job to move here For very special jobs of critical need perhaps. For broader economic immigration I’d rather have a visa categories requiring initial (and in some categories periodic subsequent) payment than a job requirement, either for initial entry or conitnued residency.
- jedberg 5y agoSo instead of requiring a job you want to require the immigrant to pay to stay? That's how you end up with only rich people getting to stay and also using it as a shortcut to immigration.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> So instead of requiring a job you want to require the immigrant to pay to stay? Mostly, no, for immigrant economic visas I’d prefer “pay to enter”. For non-immigrant including dual-intent economic visas (e.g., replacing things like H-1b), periodic payment makes sense. > That's how you end up with only rich people getting to stay Visa categories gated on high-need, high-education job categories, especially when they also come with prevailing wage requirements, also only allow rich people to come or stay. Allowing payment (which can be subsidized by friends, family, or other supportive community) actually weakens the tie to personal wealth, though it does not (nor does it intend to; this is, after all, a proposed reform of economic visa categories, not family-based, refugee, etc. ones[0]) remove it entirely. > and also using it as a shortcut to immigration. I don’t see this as a problem. [0] though to the extent those are capped, i support allowing otherwise-qualified immigrants to pay to skip (and not take up space in) the queue, through a bidding system where the cost per supernumerary immigrant in a category is higher the more are admitted in a year. It serves the purpose of the limit (mitigating social costs of level of immigration) by an alternate means, and reduces the adverse impact of the limit, not just for the people paying but also for the people not paying. It’s a win-win-win change. (A loss for thr source countries, in many cases, though.)
- unishark 5y agoIt's not just a US thing. The grace period to find a new job might be higher elsewhere though.
- jedberg 5y agoYeah a lot of countries are brutal in that respect, but it's still wrong.
- dudul 5y agoAren't we confusing 2 different things here? Visas you get through employment - eg H1B - are specifically non immigrant visas. You are not an immigrant when you are in the US with an H1B. Are they restriction on green cards too? I thought once you got your GC you didn't lose status for being fired.