3 ms·
It's the natural outcome of stack-ranking systems. If managers know that the bottom 10% of their direct reports are going to be shown the door, protect the who
by cratermoon 5y ago
It's the natural outcome of stack-ranking systems. If managers know that the bottom 10% of their direct reports are going to be shown the door, protect the whole team by hiring people just to rank them in the bottom. If a manager oversees 200 people, is more likely ~20 of them will be bad hires and can be let go, but if a manager only has five direct reports, losing just one, even if that one isn't all the great, means losing 20% of the team.
On that note, I wonder how these forces might work to fix ideal team size to align with these flawed incentives.
- procombo 5y agoGenuine question. Who in their right mind has/wants more than 10 or 20 direct reports? Any more than that seems like absolute chaos. Most I ever had was 8. When it got larger than that I had people step up to active leadership roles. Eventually they did the same.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoDepends on the nature of the work. In a tech workplace 20 is probably a real handful.
- jfrunyon 5y agoThere are plenty of teams at Amazon which could be significantly larger than that. How many employees do you think they have in every warehouse, and how many managers? ;)
- procombo 5y agoTrue. :) There is definitely a difference in how Amazon scales management for warehouses. Elsewhere, it's "everyone a leader". My first true corporate experience was with big-four Deloitte. The culture there is "up or out". May sound sketchy to outsiders but it was actually a really supportive environment.
- kilroy123 5y agoI would be furious if I got hired at a place for this reason. I already feel very uncomfortable if I'm "the dumbest person in the room". Equally, I don't want to be the smartest.