3 ms·
>> You gotta remember that automation also reduces the cost of these kinds of devices, allowing more people to acquire these devices and automate their tasks, p
by phkahler 5y ago
>> You gotta remember that automation also reduces the cost of these kinds of devices, allowing more people to acquire these devices and automate their tasks, pushing the entire population up the productivity value ladder.
Putting people out of work is not pushing anyone up a ladder. As one person gets more productive with automation their peers lose jobs.
From an economic perspective, if a factory owner replaces people with automation it's because it costs less. Hiring an automation expert and all the associated costs is a net win for them. But those jobs are higher paying, so we know it takes fewer people at the higher rate to achieve the owners lower cost.
>> Smartphones enable numerous tasks that people once had to hire another person to do for them, to be done automatically.
So first the automation put people out of work making smart phones. You try to counter that negative effect by pointing out how the phones help people but... Now the smart phones are making people more efficient, which as you say will eliminate more jobs.
Automation always eliminates jobs. The only time it frees up people to do other things is when those things are lower market value than what they were already doing - almost by definition.
I'm not against automation BTW, just against the common fiction that it's economically good for the working class.
- neonological 5y agoYou need to realize that there exists the possibility of being both good and bad. Pushing this narrative without considering the obvious facts is a simple minded view. Cheaper products are good for the working class because it means they can afford more products. Automation leads to cheaper products. Common sense. That is the good side of automation for the working class. So the answer is far more complicated then the simpleton answer you came up with here. The more you automate things the cheaper things get but the less jobs are available. The gradient is somewhere in the middle you can't completely have no automation otherwise every product will be custom made and expensive as hell. You can't have 100 percent automation either otherwise there's no one around to have jobs and make money to buy the product. So economically speaking automation is both good and bad for the working class and only a cost benefite analysis can find the right amount automation that is best. There free education for you. A lesson in basic math (see my other replies to your misguided views on quaternions) and economics in one day. I'm not so bold Like you as to run around offering paid consulting work for these trivial lessons.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoThere are innumerable services that will still be in demand, and not automatable, if nail work is automated, so consumer spending, and with it jobs, will just move there. >>I'm not against automation BTW, just against the common fiction that it's economically good for the working class. Wages in the West have grown 20 fold, in inflation adjusted terms, since 1820, and that's all due to automation. Automation is practically synonynous with per capita productivity growth, and that's almost entirely positive for every one.